Chapter 3 - What Benjamin Was Afraid to Say

The next morning, I returned to the Moretti residence expecting to be dismissed.

Instead, Mrs. Alvarez met me at the service entrance with a cup of tea and eyes that suggested she hadn't slept much. The house was quiet. Last night's flowers remained in their arrangements, but the champagne flutes were gone, and the dining table had been cleared.

"Mr. Moretti wants to hear from everyone who served dinner," she said. "Separately. He doesn't want people comparing stories."

I understood why. A man who controlled businesses across the Midwest would know how easily the truth could get lost when employees were frightened of their jobs. In his house, even an innocent mistake could become dangerous once someone decided to protect a powerful person.

"Did Benjamin finish eating?" I asked.

"Every bite. His father stayed until he did."

That was the first good thing I had heard since the previous evening.

Gabriel called me into a small office off the main corridor. He wore a charcoal suit this time, though his collar was open, exposing the edge of the black lion tattoo on his left neck. A stack of event papers lay on the desk. He remained standing while I entered.

"I owe you an apology," he said.

I blinked. "Sir?"

"My son asked for dinner three times in my own house. You noticed. I didn't."

"You had guests."

"That doesn't change what happened."

He invited me to sit and asked me to begin with the first time I heard Benjamin ask. I told him I couldn't give an exact minute, only the order of events. Benjamin had asked quietly while another guest was being served. Later he asked again. Near the end of the long wait he asked me directly and told me he'd eaten nothing since lunch.

Gabriel wrote it down without making me turn a rough recollection into a precise clock time.

"Did Vanessa speak to you before you brought the plate?"

"No. The first time she addressed me about Benjamin was when she ordered me to remove it."

He closed his pen. "Thank you. That's enough."

I stood, but he asked one more question. "Why do you think he said it was okay?"

"I can't speak for him. He looked worried."

Gabriel lowered his eyes to the notes. "He was worried about you."

The answer came from Benjamin later that morning. I was carrying clean glasses past the family breakfast room when Gabriel called me in. Benjamin sat beside him with toast on his plate. He appeared uncomfortable to see me standing in the doorway.

"Ben," Gabriel said gently, "Claire hasn't done anything wrong. I told you that last night. Will you tell her what you told me?"

Benjamin looked down at his hands.

"Vanessa said the serving people could lose their jobs if I kept asking for things. She said a nice boy wouldn't make trouble at a grown-up party."

I felt the back of my throat tighten. I had thought his whisper at dinner was an attempt to avoid embarrassing Vanessa. Now I understood it was also an attempt to protect me.

"You didn't cause trouble," I told him. "I was supposed to help you."

"But she said if the staff got blamed, it would be because I couldn't behave."

Gabriel moved his chair closer to his son. "That isn't true. No one loses a job for giving you dinner. If anyone tells you otherwise, tell me."

Benjamin hesitated. "You were busy."

There was no accusation in his voice, which somehow made it worse. Gabriel kept his expression steady, but his hand stopped moving on the table.

"I was," he admitted. "I should have listened anyway."

When I stepped back into the corridor, I saw Vanessa coming from the front hall. Her diamond earrings were gone, replaced by small gold hoops, but she carried the same certainty she had shown at dinner.

"Claire. A word."

She stopped beside an arrangement of white roses. "You embarrassed me in front of my guests."

"I served Benjamin dinner."

"You made a private family matter into a spectacle. Now Gabriel thinks everyone in this house is lying to him."

"I answered his questions."

Vanessa's mouth tightened. "People who work for families like this learn discretion. I hope you aren't confusing a few minutes of attention with being indispensable."

I didn't answer. I had no intention of entering a contest over who belonged in that house. I was worried about a child who seemed frightened to ask for a meal.

Later, Mrs. Alvarez showed Gabriel the earlier drafts of the dinner schedule. The original version assigned Benjamin a place at the main table with ordinary dinner service. In the final version, his meal had been marked as completed upstairs. The change had been transmitted from the account Vanessa used to approve event arrangements.

"Did she have authority to change the service schedule?" Gabriel asked.

"Yes, sir," Mrs. Alvarez answered. "She was handling the celebration."

"Did she have authority to tell people I'd approved a meal I hadn't seen?"

The kitchen supervisor shook her head.

It should have ended there: one false instruction, one embarrassing dinner, an apology owed to a little boy. But Gabriel kept reading. Among the routine supplies and meal orders were copies of weekly household notes prepared for him. They covered previous dinners when he had been working late or entertaining outside the house.

Three notes included the same phrase: Benjamin preferred to dine privately.

Another described him as resistant when asked to follow the family's evening schedule.

Mrs. Alvarez looked stricken. "Sir, he usually asks to eat with you. We were told you wanted quieter dinners."

"Who told you?"

"The instructions came through Ms. Bellini's household arrangements."

Gabriel did not raise his voice. He laid the pages flat, as carefully as he had placed Benjamin's dinner plate back in front of him.

"Bring me every version of these notes," he said. "From the beginning."

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Forced His Maid to Kneel Before Her...

I looked at the stack growing on the desk. Last night had not been a single careless decision at an engagement party. Someone had been telling the household one story about what Gabriel wanted and telling Gabriel another story about the child living beneath his roof.

And Benjamin had been caught in the middle long before I carried him that plate.