Chapter 3 - The Approval I Never Made

At twelve nineteen, I followed Nathaniel into a small sitting room adjoining the ballroom.

He didn't take my arm. He didn't ask me to keep wearing his coat. When I offered it back, he told me I could hold on to it until I was ready to leave.

I kept it folded over my forearms instead.

The door remained partly open. Beyond it, I could still hear music and the distant rise and fall of voices. The gala continued as though my world hadn't changed twice in the space of twenty minutes.

“Tell me what you know,” I said.

Nathaniel didn't immediately answer. He called a woman whose name he gave as Miriam Voss and asked her to join us. When she arrived, she carried a narrow document case rather than a purse.

“Miriam handles the independent review of our transportation contracts,” he explained. “She's not employed by Blackridge.”

She greeted me without the false sympathy I'd grown accustomed to hearing that night.

“We've been comparing what Pinehaven actually transported with what Blackridge submitted as contracted freight and labor costs,” she said. “Some of the supporting payroll figures don't match.”

“Cedar Gate,” I said.

Miriam looked at Nathaniel, then back at me.

“Yes.”

I thought about the discrepancy reports sitting in a folder at home. At first I'd assumed the errors came from rushed data entry. One driver's hours were charged to two locations on the same day. Another project's labor total changed without a revised time sheet. Each time I raised a question, Daniel assured me finance had reviewed it.

“I'm a payroll clerk,” I said. “I don't approve freight agreements.”

“That's why the certification caught our attention.”

Miriam opened her case and showed me a printed summary. She didn't ask me to take it or sign anything. She pointed to the part labeled with my full name and the designation of payroll verification officer.

It was my name.

It wasn't my job title.

The certificate purported to confirm that labor charges supporting the East Fork agreement had been reconciled against payroll records. The amount was enormous. The digital approval time read 11:58 p.m.

I examined it twice.

“I didn't approve this.”

“Where were you at that time?” she asked.

“At my table. I was here before midnight. There are photographs. The ceremony was starting.”

“That's important,” Miriam said. “But the audit will need more than your recollection.”

I appreciated the honesty. I had spent eleven months mistaking reassurance for truth. I preferred an answer that admitted what still needed proof.

“Could someone have used my password?” I asked.

“Possibly. We don't yet know how the approval was created. The source system logs and administrator records matter.”

Nathaniel stood by the open doorway, listening. His presence still unsettled me. Every account of Pinehaven suggested he possessed the kind of authority that could make problems disappear. I didn't want my name attached to a different set of secrets just because he appeared to be on my side.

“What does this have to do with you?” I asked him.

“Pinehaven has a freight agreement with Blackridge,” he said. “They're claiming charges against that relationship which my auditors cannot substantiate. If I accept their figures, I inherit a financial dispute I didn't create.”

“So you're protecting your company.”

“Yes.”

His directness surprised me.

“Then why the coat?”

He looked toward the ballroom. “Because I watched three hundred people decide your humiliation was entertainment. And because I'd just learned that someone put your name on the papers I came to question. I didn't want Grant taking you into a private room before you knew that.”

It wasn't a declaration of love. I was grateful for that.

“Do you expect something from me in return?”

“An honest account of your work, if you choose to give it. Not tonight, if you're not ready. And preferably through a lawyer who answers to you.”

Miriam nodded. “I would recommend independent counsel before you speak formally with either company.”

I held the edge of the paper down with one finger. Somewhere on a Blackridge server, a record claimed I'd certified figures I had never seen. Grant already knew about it. Daniel's sudden fear suggested he did too.

“I reported irregularities,” I said. “Three times. I kept my own notes of the dates and report numbers.”

Miriam straightened. “Do you still have them?”

“At home.”

“Keep them safe. Don't alter them. Don't go into company records on our behalf.”

“What about the emails I sent?”

“Preserve whatever you lawfully have,” she said. “Your lawyer can make a formal request for the rest.”

The distinction mattered. I didn't want anyone later claiming I'd stolen material because Nathaniel Mercer told me to.

Beyond the door, the gala's announcer invited guests to remain for the closing toast. Nathaniel checked his phone.

“Grant has postponed the document presentation,” he said. “But he may still want the evening to appear normal.”

I pictured Madeline's silver bracelet and Daniel's relieved smile. They had made their public alliance. Now everyone wanted the paperwork to behave.

My phone lit up.

A message from Daniel.

We need to sort this out before you say something you regret.

No apology. Not even a question about whether I was all right.

I turned the screen toward Miriam. She told me not to respond until I had spoken with counsel.

Another message followed.

You've always trusted me, Emma.

That was what hurt most. He was still trying to use the trust he had broken.

Nathaniel noticed me looking at the messages.

“Did he tell you to ignore the Cedar Gate discrepancies?”

“Yes.”

“Do you have his response?”

“I wrote it in my notebook after he called me into his office. He also replied to one email.”

Miriam made a note. Nothing in her expression suggested that one notebook would solve everything. But for the first time, my small acts of caution seemed more valuable than the powerful people's speeches.

I left the sitting room before the closing toast. Nathaniel had not asked me to stay, and Grant did not stop me in front of the guests. At the entrance, I handed back the coat.

“You may need a copy of that certificate,” I said.

“Your lawyer will have a proper way to request it,” Nathaniel answered.

I drove home with the heater failing twice on the road. My hands still shook as I climbed the stairs above the laundromat.

The notebook was exactly where I'd left it, tucked beside my desk. I opened it to the first Cedar Gate entry and found three dates marked with a question mark.

Then I tried to sign in to my work email to locate Daniel's reply.

My access had been suspended.

A message from human resources had reached my personal address twelve minutes earlier. It said an immediate review required me to surrender my company credentials and refrain from contacting colleagues about confidential matters.

It did not mention the forged certification.

It did not explain why the suspension had arrived after midnight.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

I looked at my notebook, then at the message.

Someone had begun protecting the records before I'd even reached home. And I was beginning to understand which records they wanted me to stop asking about.