Chapter 7 - Why She Needed Elena to Hate Him

Luca did not confront Vanessa that night. Jonah persuaded him to wait until the independent reviewer could verify the remaining financial records. A message about keeping him unaware until a signing was serious, but Luca wanted to be certain the signing mattered for the reason they suspected. He had already canceled his approval of the waterfront venture. Now he needed to understand why the Bellini family had spent so much effort trying to prevent him from speaking openly with Elena.

The answer began with a bank archive. After comparing account numbers from Vittorio's original note with the references in Carlo's discharge certificate, the reviewer obtained authenticated historical statements through the institutions involved. The documents showed the original eight-million-dollar advance leaving the Moretti holding company and reaching Bellini Development. They did not show the repayment claimed in Carlo's certificate. A purported offset mentioned by Bellini's legal coordinator was also unsupported by any executed agreement in the records provided.

Jonah did not declare the matter settled. Claims that old debts remain enforceable can depend on dates, amendments, notices, and applicable law. But the documentation was enough to show that the company's old accounting entry could not be trusted. He advised Luca to preserve the evidence, reject the broad release, and seek formal explanations from Carlo through counsel.

Elena's blue portfolio supplied another crucial connection. Behind the signed note was an attachment identifying the precise warehouse-lease revenue assigned as security. The same revenue appeared in a financing presentation Carlo's company had recently circulated for the new hotel venture, described as free of existing claims. The description might have been corrected by later lawful transactions, but Bellini Development had produced no documents proving that such a correction was justified.

Luca phoned Elena personally. "You kept this when you didn't have to," he told her.

"I kept a box that was stored with our property files," she answered. "When I learned what was inside, I wanted it handled properly."

He thanked her for refusing to surrender the originals to anyone without a record. She reminded him that the portfolio was not an invitation to repair their marriage. They had divorced four years earlier, and the sale of the vacation home was still a separate matter. Luca agreed. Neither needed to become close again for the truth about the documents to be established.

The reviewer then found the explanation for the archive request. An older inventory of the vacation home's contents, prepared when Luca and Elena separated, listed "blue Moretti business portfolio" among stored papers. Copies of that inventory had been available to the property manager and the owners' representatives. Vanessa's office had requested an updated inventory shortly before the restaurant photographs were taken. Mercer later confirmed that Vanessa had shown him the older listing and asked whether he could establish that Elena still controlled the box.

I understood why Vanessa had focused on Elena. The portfolio had been in a house Elena co-owned and was helping to sell. Elena had legal access to the stored papers. Luca, trusting the older corporate records, hadn't realized an original Bellini financing agreement remained there. Vanessa wanted the gap between what they each knew to last just long enough for Luca to sign the release.

But something still bothered me. "If she wanted you not to receive the papers," I asked Luca, "why tell Elena you were about to marry her? Wouldn't that make Elena call you?"

"Not if Elena believed I'd lied to her throughout our marriage," he answered. "She might have refused to speak to me at all."

It was cruel because it was plausible. Vanessa understood that an accusation of a five-year affair could reopen old injuries and make a former spouse distrust any request for cooperation. Elena might have retained the portfolio with her lawyer rather than returning it, leaving the missing original out of Luca's hands while he dealt with the wedding and the venture. The photographs did not need to prove anything. They needed only to make a false story sound credible.

Luca finally arranged a meeting with Vanessa in his study. He told her the waterfront signing was canceled pending verification of historical accounts. He did not yet accuse her of arranging my injury. He asked whether she knew of any unresolved obligation between her father and Vittorio Moretti.

Vanessa hesitated. "My father has had hundreds of business arrangements," she said. "Why are you suddenly asking about one from years ago?"

"Because the release your father's advisers sent me refers to it."

She said that Carlo was worried about the hotel's financing timetable and that delay could damage both families. Luca asked why her office had requested the inventory of his vacation home. Vanessa said she'd been helping coordinate household matters before the wedding and assumed the sale was part of those arrangements. When Luca asked why Mercer had been admitted to his guest room, she described him as a consultant.

"A consultant who photographed my former wife?" Luca asked.

Vanessa's composure faltered. She admitted she had hired Mercer to look into Elena because she believed Elena might interfere with the wedding. Luca didn't reveal the saved messages. Instead, he asked why she'd instructed Mercer to tell Elena about a five-year affair that had never happened.

Vanessa looked away. "I was angry," she said. "I thought if Elena heard you were marrying me, she'd cause trouble."

"So you planned to tell her we were together while I was still married?"

"I wanted her to stay away from us."

Luca told her that anger didn't explain the broad financial release or the archive request. Vanessa said she had merely trusted her father's advisers. She offered no explanation for telling Mercer to keep Luca unaware until the signing. Her answers grew narrower as his questions became more specific.

Before leaving the study, Luca asked about my injury. Vanessa repeated that I'd walked into the pantry door. He told her he had reviewed the hallway footage and knew it wasn't true. For the first time, she stopped speaking altogether. Luca said they would continue the conversation with counsel present and asked her to keep away from me. He did not give her the opportunity to replace the camera record with another unchallenged story.

When Mrs. Carter told me the next morning that Vanessa had been asked not to contact me, I felt both relief and dread. I knew she'd learn eventually that the footage had been preserved. I also knew the mansion would never feel ordinary again. Still, Luca had not asked me to withdraw my statement for the sake of his engagement, and that mattered.

That afternoon, Jonah received a formal response from Carlo's advisers. Bellini Development disputed that any money remained due and proposed a private settlement discussion. But the draft settlement again contained the same broad release, now accompanied by a confidentiality clause restricting disclosure of the historical financing records. It offered Luca a way to end the dispute quietly while leaving the unexplained accounting intact.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

Luca declined. He told Jonah to demand supporting financial documents before any negotiation. The old loan was no longer the only issue. Carlo's company had funded surveillance of Luca's former wife, Vanessa had tried to manipulate Elena, and an employee had been injured while overhearing the plan. Separating those acts would be necessary for accountability. Treating them as a single inconvenience to be settled in private would repeat the mistake that had allowed them to grow.

That evening, Daniel confirmed one final detail from Mercer's records: Vanessa had personally approved the message instructing him to keep Elena angry and Luca unaware. Her father had supplied the business account used for payment, but the language of the lie was hers. Luca now had evidence of both the financial motive and the personal decision behind it. The question was no longer whether Vanessa knew what she was doing. It was how far Carlo had encouraged it, and what Luca would do when they faced him together.