Chapter 8 - The Box at Lake Forest

The missing witness was seventy-four now and lived in a brick bungalow west of the city.

His name was Arthur Pell. He had been a night supervisor at the maintenance company when Matteo died, and he remembered the Bellini house because he'd never been called to replace a stair tread while police were still outside a property. The detective who contacted him found that he'd kept his work diary with the old invoices when he retired.

I didn't go to his home. Nina told me there were parts of the investigation best handled by people trained to take statements without suggesting answers. Arthur's account reached us through his lawyer-approved summary after he spoke to the police.

He had seen a broken oak step with a deep mark near its edge. There was no damaged railing. Richard told him the blood on the landing had been cleaned because it upset his daughter. Arthur had pointed out that somebody should document the area before the work began. Richard said he had permission. Arthur never saw that permission.

An officer had taken his name. It appeared on one preliminary scene log, but not in the report later given to Luca's family. Investigators were reviewing why. Nina warned that an omission wasn't, by itself, proof the police had conspired with Richard.

“That distinction matters,” she told Luca. “If we claim more than we can prove, Richard will spend his energy attacking that claim instead of answering the evidence we actually have.”

He nodded. I saw how much effort it cost him to accept patience when all he wanted was an answer for his brother.

The following day the police obtained a warrant for the Lake Forest storage unit associated with Harbor Advisory. It had taken sworn accounts, financial records, and the information Vanessa provided to establish the grounds for searching. Nobody at the mansion went there. We learned what they could share afterward.

The metal archive box was exactly where Vanessa said it would be. Inside were copies of settlement agreements, Elena's original signed denial, records of payments to several former employees, and a packet of trust documents. A page in Richard's handwriting instructed an administrator to release a Harbor Advisory payment only after “the Rossi statement” had been signed.

The original statement said Elena had seen no disagreement between Richard and Matteo, had received no threats, and was leaving Chicago voluntarily. Her attorney showed her a scan before the investigators asked her to identify it. She remembered the room at the hospital where she'd signed, the lawyer's silver pen, and the way her hands had shaken.

“I wish I'd refused,” she said to Nina afterward, during a call I was allowed to attend. “But I was looking at a photograph of Mara. I believed they'd hurt her.”

“You're telling them the truth now,” I said.

She took a breath. “I hope that matters to you, Emily. I heard about the dinner.”

“It matters,” I replied. “It doesn't erase what happened. But it matters.”

Elena asked about my wrist. I told her the bruises were fading. She said she was glad, and neither of us pretended fading bruises meant the fear went away at the same speed.

The accountant's full tracing report also arrived. Bank records supported that Harbor Advisory, controlled through Richard's business associates, had received transfers from the Bellini Community Trust with no adequate evidence of legitimate services. The approval supposedly signed by Matteo had been certified after his death. Another document authorized funds to the same company less than a month before Matteo confronted Richard. The money explained the argument at the house and showed why Richard needed to discredit the person who helped Matteo discover it.

“Then the trust was paying to hide complaints?” I asked.

“Some payments correspond to those settlements,” Nina said. “The investigation will determine which transactions were unlawful and who authorized each one. We shouldn't turn every line on the spreadsheet into a victim we haven't met.”

She showed us a separate copy of Claire's proposed agreement. The same law firm that had sent her an offer now demanded that she retract her accusation against Vanessa. Richard's pattern was visible without turning anyone's suffering into a number.

Investigators connected the courier envelope containing my mother's photograph to an account billed through Harbor Advisory. A staff member at the courier service identified the person who had arranged the delivery. The evidence didn't yet tell us whether Richard had typed the note himself. It did put the threat within his organization, and Nina helped me add it to my complaint.

My mother heard the news while stirring soup at her kitchen stove.

“Are you happy?” she asked.

“I thought I would be.”

She lowered the heat. “Maybe you're tired.”

I was. I was tired of waking up to notifications, tired of wondering if the next letter would name my apartment, tired of feeling responsible for what would happen to Luca when he learned one more terrible thing. But I wasn't sorry I'd spoken.

“I want him held accountable,” I said. “I also want to stop measuring my life by what Richard might do next.”

“Then make a plan for your own life, sweetheart. Even before his is finished.”

That night I began looking into community college courses in patient advocacy and hospital administration. I'd learned too much helping my mother navigate treatment to think it was knowledge I should keep only for myself. The possibility frightened me almost as much as the case. I had been thinking in one-month stretches for so long that imagining another year felt extravagant.

At the mansion Luca found the application brochure I'd left on the sideboard. He read the heading but didn't pick it up.

“You're thinking of leaving?” he asked.

“Eventually. I want work that doesn't depend on a guest deciding whether I'm respectable.”

He looked down at his hands. “I would miss you.”

“I know.”

His eyes lifted. Nothing else was said. It was the first time I understood that whatever had begun between us might be real, and the first time I knew it needed distance from my paycheck if it was going to be anything worth keeping.

At nine that evening Daniel arrived with news of a call to Luca's lawyer. Richard wanted a meeting at the mansion. He offered to withdraw his threat against me and to “settle Elena's misunderstandings” if Luca persuaded the witnesses to stop cooperating with investigators. In return, he wanted Luca to issue a statement saying the trust documents were a family dispute, not fraud.

“We don't have to meet him,” Nina said when Luca called her.

“I won't pressure anyone,” Luca replied. “But he keeps trying to turn this into a private bargain. I want him told, in front of his own counsel, that there is no bargain.”

Nina insisted on safeguards: the police would be informed of the proposed meeting, witnesses would attend only voluntarily, lawyers would be present, and any recording would be openly disclosed and agreed to. She would not permit evidence to be exchanged or promises made that could interfere with the investigation.

Claire declined to attend. Elena agreed only after talking with her lawyer. Vanessa said she would come to tell Richard, in his presence, that she'd corrected her statement. I agreed to sit beside Nina because I wanted Richard to hear the word no from somebody he'd once ordered onto her knees.

The night before the meeting, Luca stood in the dining room staring at the chair beside his place at the table.

“I don't know how I'm going to look at him without thinking of Matteo,” he said.

“You don't have to forget Matteo to stay in control,” I told him.

He turned toward me. “And you don't have to come because you think I'll need you.”

“I know.”

I looked at the repaired seam of the apron I'd kept in a drawer, untouched since the night of the dinner.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

“I'm coming because he needs to hear the person he tried to silence.”

The next morning Richard Bellini arrived at the Moretti mansion carrying a leather briefcase and the confidence of a man who still believed every problem could be settled by making somebody else afraid.