validate

Chapter 8 - The Conversation She Chose

When Meline finally agreed to see me, it was not because I had asked again.

I had stopped asking.

Her attorney called on a rainy afternoon in late November and said Meline wanted one conversation before deciding how to proceed with the marriage. She would choose the place. Sofia would be nearby. Neither of us would bring recording devices or discuss the pending criminal case beyond what we already knew.

I agreed to every condition.

We met in a private sitting room at a counseling center where Meline had been receiving support. The room contained two chairs, a low table, and a window overlooking a courtyard full of bare branches. There were no chandeliers. No expensive arrangements of flowers. Nobody waiting to remove an obstacle from my path.

Meline arrived in a gray sweater and dark trousers. Her hair was pulled back loosely. She looked thinner than I remembered, but the change that frightened me was in her eyes. She regarded me without the expectation that I might make things better.

"Hello, Damen," she said.

I stood. "Meline."

She sat first. I waited until she had settled before taking the opposite chair.

"You don't need to tell me you're sorry," she said. "I've read your letter."

I had sent one through Rahman weeks earlier. No flowers. No expensive pen. Three pages of things I should have said when it mattered, written without a request for her to respond.

"I am sorry," I said anyway.

"I know."

She folded her hands in her lap. Her wedding ring was gone. I noticed it because I had spent years taking its presence for granted.

"Sofia says you've been cooperating," she said. "With the hospital. With the investigation."

"Yes."

"Good."

Her voice remained flat. Then she looked toward the courtyard.

"I want you to understand something. I didn't leave because I thought Elena was more important to you. I knew that already. I left because when our son died, I realized I had been waiting for you in more ways than one."

I listened.

"I waited at dinner for you to put down the phone. I waited at appointments. I waited when you promised you would come home. And in the hospital, when they told me we had to deliver him, I waited again."

She drew a breath that trembled despite her careful control.

"I kept thinking, surely someone has told him now. Surely this will be the thing that makes him come."

I gripped my knees beneath the table.

"I should have been there."

"Yes."

The simplicity of her answer left no room for defense.

"The doctors were kind," she continued. "Sofia came as soon as she could. Nora stayed after her shift ended. There were people who helped me. But you were his father. I wanted you to see him while I still had him in my arms."

I could barely speak. "I wish I had."

"Wishing is easy now."

The words did not come as an attack. She sounded tired of explaining something that had once been obvious.

"Did you ever love her?" Meline asked.

I could have answered with distinctions. Infatuation. Escape. Vanity. The addictive relief of being admired without being asked to take responsibility. All those words had some truth in them.

"I chose to be with her," I said. "For eight months. I lied to you and made you doubt what you could see. Whatever I called it, I betrayed you."

She nodded once.

"Thank you for not making me argue about that."

There was a long silence. I heard footsteps pass in the hallway and a door close somewhere down the corridor.

"I remember the moment I fell," she said. "I remember telling Elena to stop. She had hold of my arm, and I was trying to get to the obstetric elevator. I didn't think the baby would die. I thought I would be frightened, examined, perhaps sent home. Even after they rushed me into surgery, I kept believing we'd somehow be all right."

"Meline—"

She lifted a hand. I stopped.

"I don't want you to carry the idea that you could have performed some miracle in that operating room. Dr. Harper told me she couldn't promise a different outcome. But don't use that uncertainty to pretend your presence wouldn't have mattered."

"I won't."

"Elena is responsible for her actions. Bernard is responsible for his. You are responsible for yours. I'm tired of having men tell me one person's wrongdoing explains another's."

I looked at her, understanding that this was why she had come. Not to hear about legal evidence I could assemble with other people's help. To tell me where the limits of my responsibility began and ended, and to refuse to let me move those limits for my own comfort.

"I want a divorce," she said.

I had known it since the separation papers arrived. Knowing did not make the words painless.

"I won't contest it."

"Our attorneys can work out the property. I won't sign anything that prevents me from speaking about Oliver. Or about what happened to me."

"I wouldn't ask you to."

She turned her face back toward me.

"You asked me to be quiet for years without ever saying those words. I need you to hear how different this has to be."

I nodded. "I hear you."

For a brief moment I thought she might cry. Instead she reached into her bag and removed a small photograph. She placed it on the table between us, facing me.

Oliver lay wrapped in a white blanket, wearing the blue hat. His face was still, delicate, and unmistakably his own. I could see what Meline had meant about his nose. The resemblance was there, but it seemed obscene to think of it as a claim I could make.

I covered my mouth.

"That's our son," she said.

I nodded because words were beyond me.

She let me look. She did not rush me. After a while, she drew the photograph back and placed it safely in her bag.

"You may keep the footprints," she said. "And the hat. I wanted you to have something of him."

"Thank you."

"You don't need to thank me for letting you be his father. You already were."

Her eyes filled then. So did mine. For a few moments there was nothing between us but a grief too large for the room.

When she stood, I stood too, but I did not reach for her.

"Take care of yourself, Damen," she said.

"You too."

At the doorway she paused.

"I loved you very much," she said. "That doesn't mean I can live with you again."

Then she left.

I stayed in the chair until Sofia came quietly to make certain I understood the meeting was over. I told her I did.

Outside, rain had begun to gather along the curb. I walked to my car without opening an umbrella.

May you like

Meline had given me a photograph, an answer, and the truth about our marriage.

None of those things was permission to ask for more.

Related Stories

Other posts