Chapter 12 - Gretchen Testified About the Moment Murder Became a Plan

Gretchen entered through a side door.

The jury watched her carefully.

Everyone knew she had pleaded guilty.

Everyone knew she had lied during cooperation.

That made her dangerous to both sides.

The prosecutor began with the worst facts first.

“Did you help plan Claire Hartwell’s death?”

“Yes.”

“Did you research hiking locations?”

“Yes.”

“Did you suggest hiking was safer than a vehicle crash for the plan?”

“Yes.”

“Did you expect to benefit?”

“Yes.”

Brandon’s attorney looked almost pleased.

A liar admitting crimes.

Easy target.

Then the prosecutor asked Gretchen why she was testifying.

“To receive consideration at sentencing.”

Not redemption.

Not conscience.

A benefit.

That honesty helped.

She explained the affair.

Brandon’s debt.

Cole.

The first jokes.

The first serious conversation.

The route research.

The insurance.

The storage unit.

Moving my backpack.

Buying the prepaid phone.

The more she admitted, the uglier she became.

And the more believable the remaining details sounded.

The prosecutor played one recording.

Gretchen’s voice: “What if she survives?”

Brandon: “She won’t.”

Gretchen: “What if she does?”

Brandon: “Then I finish it.”

No one moved.

Gretchen stared at the table.

The prosecutor asked, “What did you understand that to mean?”

“That he would kill her himself if the fall didn’t.”

Brandon’s attorney objected to interpretation.

The judge overruled.

Then Gretchen described Glacier.

She waited near the trailhead.

Brandon called.

“It’s done.”

She walked toward the cliff.

She asked if I was dead.

Brandon gave the fifty-million-dollar answer.

“Did you call for help?”

“No.”

“Why?”

“Because I wanted her dead too.”

I was not prepared for that.

Not the admission.

The clarity.

Gretchen finally looked toward me.

“I’m sorry.”

The prosecutor immediately redirected.

“Ms. Vale, please answer only the question.”

Good.

I did not want her apology turned into theater.

Cross-examination began.

Brandon’s attorney attacked every lie.

The trust.

Cole.

The referral fee.

Her initial denial.

Her revised deal.

“You will receive a lower sentence if the government believes you helped them convict Brandon Hartwell.”

“Yes.”

“So you have every reason to please them.”

“I have a reason to tell the truth.”

“You also had a reason to lie before.”

“Yes.”

The attorney paced.

“Isn’t it true you hated Claire?”

“No.”

“You wanted her husband.”

“Yes.”

“You wanted her life.”

Gretchen paused.

“I thought I did.”

“You researched the trail.”

“Yes.”

“You suggested hiking.”

“Yes.”

“You moved Claire’s belongings.”

“Yes.”

“You touched her phone.”

“Yes.”

The attorney turned toward the jury.

Then back.

“And now you want them to believe Brandon was the mastermind.”

Gretchen looked at him.

“No.”

That surprised everyone.

“Excuse me?”

“I was part of it.”

The attorney frowned.

“I’m not asking them to believe I was innocent.”

He tried another angle.

“Did you physically see Brandon push Claire?”

“No.”

There.

The defense needed that.

“You were not at the cliff when the alleged push occurred.”

“No.”

“So everything you know about the actual fall came from Brandon.”

“Yes.”

“And he told you only, ‘It’s done.’”

“Yes.”

“Which could mean she slipped.”

Gretchen almost laughed.

“No.”

“Why not?”

“Because we had spent weeks planning for him to push her.”

The attorney’s face hardened.

The prosecutor objected to the argument.

The judge instructed the jury.

But the point remained.

Gretchen’s testimony was not perfect.

It did not need to be.

She connected the planning to the outcome.

Then came something nobody expected.

The defense asked whether Gretchen had ever told Brandon not to go through with it.

“Yes.”

“When?”

“The night before.”

My head lifted.

This had not appeared in summaries I saw.

The attorney looked interested.

“Why?”

“I got scared.”

“And what did Brandon say?”

Gretchen glanced toward prosecutors.

They had the transcript.

“He said I was already involved.”

“What else?”

“He said if I backed out, he would tell Cole I stole part of the loan.”

Murmurs spread.

The judge called for quiet.

The defense had accidentally opened a door.

On redirect, prosecutors played the corresponding recording.

Gretchen: “I don’t want to do this.”

Brandon: “Too late.”

Gretchen: “We can leave. Sell everything.”

Brandon: “I’m not becoming poor because you got sentimental.”

Gretchen: “What if I tell Claire?”

Brandon’s voice changed.

“If you warn her, there will be two accidents.”

My skin turned cold.

Gretchen cried silently.

Not because the jury forgave her.

They shouldn’t.

But the recording changed one thing.

Brandon was willing to kill beyond me.

His plan was not the result of being manipulated by a mistress.

It was control.

Money.

Threat.

When Gretchen stepped down, she passed within ten feet of me.

She did not look over.

I was glad.

Some relationships do not need closure.

They need distance and consequences.

Court recessed.

Outside, Miriam Stone approached me alone.

“Gretchen asked me not to carry messages between you.”

“Good.”

“She also asked that any money seized from the trust go to Noah.”

“No.”

Miriam blinked.

“Why?”

“My son will never receive money attached to planning his mother’s death.”

“What should happen to it?”

“Victim compensation. Domestic violence services. Whatever the court allows.”

Miriam nodded.

That was the last conversation I ever had about Gretchen outside the courtroom.

The next morning, the prosecutor called Sebastian Cole.

He had made his own deal.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

And unlike Gretchen, Cole had spent his career keeping records because he trusted nobody.

Brandon’s financial motive was about to become arithmetic.