Chapter 16 - The Letters Matteo Wrote Without Asking Her to Wait

The first letter arrived twelve days after Matteo entered prison.
Elena left it unopened on the counter for six hours.
Then she made tea, sat at the kitchen table, and read.
Elena,
The coffee here is a crime I was never charged with.
She laughed before she could stop herself.
The letter contained no promises.
No request that she wait.
Matteo described a parenting class he had enrolled in because it counted toward his reentry plan. He admitted the instructor had asked everyone to list three things children needed from fathers and he had written protection, money, discipline.
The instructor crossed out all three.
Apparently the correct answers were presence, consistency, and emotional safety.
I am forty years old and being taught fatherhood by a woman named Brenda who wears sunflower earrings. I deserve this.
Elena read the letter twice.
Then she placed it in the nursery drawer beside Luca’s hospital bracelet.
She wrote back.
Not every week.
Not on schedule.
When she had something real to say.
Sofia cut her first tooth.
Rosa moved into a smaller house in Westchester.
Celeste testified before a grand jury and entered counseling.
Elena returned full-time to neonatal nursing, then accepted a role helping families navigate medical grants.
Months passed.
Matteo’s letters changed.
He stopped reporting prison conditions and started writing about choices.
He joined a financial-literacy program for men preparing for release.
He helped one inmate read a business contract.
He refused an offer from an old associate to pass messages outside.
The refusal cost him friendships he no longer wanted.
Elena did not romanticize any of it.
Prison did not purify people.
Suffering was not moral proof.
But consistency mattered.
Nine months after sentencing, Nikolai’s federal trial began.
Elena testified.
This time, the defense could not surprise her with photographs or insinuations.
She described Luca.
The nursery wall.
The hidden drive.
The Saint Aurelia archive.
She did not describe Matteo as a hero.
When asked whether he had participated in criminal conduct, she said yes.
When asked whether his cooperation benefited the prosecution, she said yes.
Both truths fit in the same room.
Nikolai watched her from the defense table.
He seemed smaller than he had in the clinic.
On cross-examination, his attorney asked, “Mrs. Rossi, you are emotionally involved with Matteo Volkov, correct?”
“I care about him.”
“Love him?”
The prosecutor objected.
The judge sustained.
The attorney changed direction.
“Your testimony helps the father of a child you are attached to.”
“My testimony is about documents.”
“And you want Matteo released.”
“I want him treated according to the law.”
The attorney smiled.
“Convenient.”
Elena looked at the jury.
“My husband died because people in this case believed personal loyalty mattered more than truth. I am not interested in repeating that mistake.”
The courtroom became very quiet.
Afterward, Grant found Elena in the hallway.
“That was annoyingly responsible.”
“I learned from you.”
“Then I’m billing you.”
Nikolai’s trial lasted seven weeks.
Marianne testified for three days.
Calvin Moss testified for four hours.
Celeste testified against her husband and cried only once.
Dmitri described internal security procedures and admitted the ways he had helped enforce a criminal organization even when he had not known about Nikolai’s archive.
The prosecution introduced Nadia’s recordings.
Luca’s video.
Bank records.
Server logs.
The jury convicted Nikolai on racketeering, conspiracy, extortion, kidnapping conspiracy, and charges connected to the deaths of Luca, Nico, and Leo.
The verdict did not bring Elena peace.
It brought finality to one question.
Someone had been held responsible.
That mattered.
Outside the courthouse, reporters waited.
Elena did not speak.
She went to Westchester instead.
Sofia was nearly one.
She had Matteo’s dark eyes and Nadia’s stubborn mouth.
When Elena entered, Sofia toddled three uncertain steps toward her and fell onto her padded bottom.
Then she shouted, “Lena!”
Elena froze.
Rosa clapped both hands over her mouth.
“Did she just—”
“She’s been practicing,” Rosa said.
Elena dropped to her knees.
Sofia collided with her chest.
Elena held her.
The joy hurt.
That night, she wrote Matteo.
Sofia said my name today.
I thought you should know before anyone else.
His reply arrived five days later.
I read that sentence until the paper softened.
Thank you for loving her without pretending she belongs to you.
Elena stared at the words.
Then she finally wrote what she had refused to say before sentencing.
I love you.
I am not promising a future I cannot see.
I am not promising to wait.
But I love you now, and I do not want fear to make me dishonest about it.
She mailed the letter before she could reconsider.
Three weeks later, Matteo replied with only one page.
That is more than I had the right to ask for.
So I will not ask for more.
At the bottom, he added:
Brenda says that was emotionally mature.
May you like
I hate Brenda.
Elena laughed until she cried.