Chapter 2 - What Happened the Night Grace Was Born

For a moment, the only sound in the dining room was the faint movement of the chandelier above us.
Celia's last words seemed to have changed the air. Grace stood beside her, thirteen years old and trying to make sense of a conversation no child should have discovered in front of thirty-four strangers. Anna had one hand over her mouth. Luca looked from his sister to his aunt as though the family he knew had been replaced by people wearing familiar faces.
"Tell us," he said.
Celia glanced toward the guests. "This is neither the time nor the place."
"You made it the place when you threw my sister's birthday gift into the trash."
I still held the brown-paper package. My fingers had tightened around it so firmly that a corner had wrinkled. I eased my grip and placed it on the serving table, where Anna could see it.
Grace stepped away from Celia. "Is my mother alive?"
The question was quiet. That made it worse.
Anna lowered herself to the child's eye level but did not reach for her. "Yes, sweetheart. I am."
"Then why did Grandma tell me she died?"
Celia opened her mouth. Luca raised his hand.
"You will answer that," he said. "But not before Grace has somewhere private to sit."
He asked the guests to leave. Nobody argued. Coats were collected with an efficiency I had never seen during a party, and within minutes the dining room was almost empty. The birthday cake remained beneath its candles, untouched at the end of the walnut table. I noticed two small silver candles among the others and wondered who had arranged them. It seemed a terrible time to ask.
I intended to retreat to the kitchen. I had just been fired, and standing in the center of the family disaster felt like trespassing. Luca stopped me near the doorway.
"Emma, please stay. Anna trusts you."
"Your aunt dismissed me."
"I heard. You still have your position, if you want it. That decision was not hers to make."
He did not say it as though I'd been rescued by an act of generosity. He said it as though a wrong decision had been corrected. I thought of my mother's mortgage and felt my throat tighten.
We moved into the smaller morning room. Grace sat beside the window, with Luca across from her. Anna took the chair nearest the door. Celia remained standing until Luca asked her to sit. I brought water because it was the only useful thing I could think to do.
Anna wrapped her hands around the glass but didn't drink.
"Thirteen years ago," she began, "I gave birth to Grace at St. Agnes Hospital. There were complications. I needed surgery afterward and couldn't care for a newborn by myself while I recovered. Celia came to the hospital. She said she would help for a few weeks."
Celia's eyes narrowed. "You were in no condition to make decisions."
"Which is why I trusted you to help me," Anna replied. "Not to take her from me."
Anna explained that she'd signed permission for temporary care while she recovered. She believed it would last six weeks at most. When she tried to bring Grace home, Celia said a court had decided the child would be better off remaining with the Morettis. Anna had been told she was unstable, irresponsible, and unfit.
"I had no money to fight lawyers like hers," Anna said. "I was frightened of losing even the chance to know where Grace was."
"You could have come to me," Luca said.
She looked at him with such sadness that I looked away.
"I tried. Letters came back. Calls never reached you. When I went to the gates, I was told you didn't want to see me."
Luca's gaze shifted to Celia. She said nothing.
"And my father?" Grace asked.
"You have a right to learn about him," Anna said. "But tonight, I want you to know that I didn't die. And I never stopped wanting to see you."
Grace held the glass with both hands. "Grandma said her son was my father."
Anna swallowed. "That isn't true."
Celia's face tightened. "I raised her. I was there when she had fevers. When she learned to read. When she was afraid of thunderstorms."
"Then you know what those years meant to her," Luca said. "You had thirteen chances to tell her the truth, and you chose to lie every day."
It was the first time I'd heard him speak to Celia without the careful respect that usually surrounded her. He wasn't shouting. Somehow, that made the words harder to dismiss.
Grace rose. For a moment, Anna seemed to think her daughter might come toward her. Instead, the girl asked to go upstairs and be alone.
"Of course," Anna whispered.
Luca arranged for a trusted member of the household to remain nearby if Grace needed anything. He did not force a hug or ask her to choose sides. When the door closed, Anna pressed her palms together to stop them shaking.
"What happened to the papers?" Luca asked Celia.
"They were handled legally."
"Then you can show them to me."
Celia looked toward Anna. "She didn't tell you everything about why she left this family at nineteen."
Anna's face turned pale, but she met her aunt's eyes. "I will tell him. This time you won't interrupt."
Luca turned back to me. "Emma, would you bring my sister's gift?"
I retrieved the small package. Anna took it carefully and set it in Luca's hands.
"I made this for your birthday," she told him. "I wanted you to have something I could give you even if you wouldn't speak to me."
He opened the brown paper without tearing it. Inside was a small book bound in blue cloth, its uneven stitches unmistakably made by hand. On the first page Anna had embroidered his name. The pages beyond held short birthday letters, one for each of the years she'd spent outside his life.
Luca turned them slowly. His face changed when he reached a page marked thirteen years earlier.
A photograph had been slipped into the binding. Anna held a newborn in a hospital bed, exhausted and smiling. The baby's tiny hand rested against her cheek.
On the back, in Anna's handwriting, was a date and a name: Grace.
"I wanted to show you your niece," she said. "Celia told me you refused the photograph."
Luca looked up.
May you like
"I've never seen it before."
And for the first time, Anna's expression showed not only grief but the realization that her brother had been lied to as thoroughly as she had.