Chapter 3 - Seven Minutes Without a Witness

At ten minutes past eight, Dr. Anika Shah examined Lucy in the nursery sitting room while Maria remained beside her. Nicholas waited outside with Arthur. He had asked the doctor to come because the child had been hurt, not because he wanted a medical opinion that would conveniently settle an argument.

Dr. Shah emerged carrying her bag. “There are four superficial contusions on the wrist,” she said. “Their pattern is consistent with forceful gripping. I cannot identify who caused them. She doesn't appear to have a fracture, and she's frightened but otherwise well.”

“Do I need to bring her to the hospital?” Maria asked from the doorway.

“Not unless the swelling increases or she develops pain moving her hand. I've documented what I saw and given you instructions. Please call me if anything changes.”

Nicholas thanked her. After she left, Maria stayed in the doorway, watching him as though he might reconsider his promise.

“You and Lucy can rest,” he said. “Gabriel will make sure nobody disturbs you.”

“I don't want her learning to be afraid of every adult in this house.”

“Neither do I.”

That was not a solution, and they both knew it. But Maria nodded and returned to her daughter.

Nicholas's security director, Gabriel Ortiz, met him in the study. Gabriel was a broad-shouldered man who rarely offered an opinion until he could support it. A tablet lay on the desk beside a stack of security reports.

“The corridor feed went dark at two seventeen and resumed at two twenty-four,” Gabriel said. “It wasn't a power interruption. Someone logged into the local control panel and selected privacy mode.”

“Who?”

“The account was created for guest-event management. Miss Hart requested it three weeks ago to keep visiting donors out of recorded dressing areas during the benefit preparations. I approved restricted access to the ballroom cameras, not this corridor.”

“Could someone else have used her password?”

“Yes. I can't exclude that. But the system records the device that made the change.”

He showed Nicholas an entry bearing the identifier of the small tablet Vivienne used to organize household events. A second entry showed that an administrator had expanded the account's permissions the previous afternoon.

“Who expanded them?” Nicholas asked.

“An outside technician working through the event contractor. He says he received a written request bearing Miss Hart's approval. I've asked him to preserve it.”

Nicholas stared at the two records. He had agreed to let Vivienne use the ballroom for charity planning. He had not considered that a seemingly minor permission could be widened into access to a private corridor.

“Preserve the raw logs off this network,” he said. “Don't make an accusation from a device identifier alone. Find out who was holding it.”

Gabriel nodded. “Arthur was watching the service entrance during part of that interval. He kept his written log.”

Nicholas knew the book. For decades the butler had recorded deliveries, repair visits, misplaced keys, and the time each evening's doors were locked. His habits once struck Nicholas as excessive. Tonight they were suddenly valuable.

Arthur brought in the day's entry. At two nineteen he had seen Vivienne cross from the study corridor toward the staircase carrying a blue document wallet. At two twenty-one, the foundation treasurer, Adrian Pike, had left through the service entrance. Pike had not been on the list for the afternoon's meetings.

“Why didn't you mention Pike earlier?” Nicholas asked.

“Miss Hart said he'd stopped by to discuss the benefit. He didn't enter through the front. That concerned me, so I recorded it.”

Pike had served the Eleanor House Foundation for six years. Quiet, capable, and consistently late to every Christmas dinner, he handled the organization's accounts and prepared quarterly reports for the trustees. Nicholas had entrusted him with the kind of responsibility he no longer had the time to examine daily.

“What about the envelope?” Nicholas asked.

Arthur opened the incoming correspondence tray. A place remained where a blue envelope should have been. There were three white envelopes, two charity invitations, and a handwritten note from a gardener. Nothing blue.

“I put it here before lunch,” Arthur said. His voice showed no surprise, only regret. “I should have locked it away.”

Nicholas opened his desk drawers. The papers were orderly, the pens aligned. The antique silver key to his private document cabinet lay in its usual place. There was no sign that anyone had forced the lock.

“Vivienne accused Maria of stealing a key,” he said. “The key is here.”

“It has not been missing to my knowledge, sir.”

The accusation had changed shape. Maria was supposed to have taken papers, but Vivienne had first called her a thief over a key that had never left the drawer. Nicholas felt an uncomfortable recognition. Someone had given the staff just enough uncertainty to make them hesitate before helping her.

His telephone rang. Vivienne's name filled the screen.

“I assume you've finished questioning the child,” she said when he answered.

“The doctor has seen her.”

“Then this is over.”

“It isn't. Why did Adrian Pike come to the house today?”

The pause was brief. “The charity benefit. I've told you.”

“Why use the service entrance?”

“He prefers privacy. Not everyone is comfortable around your security men.”

“And why did the camera outside my study stop recording while he was here?”

“Nicholas, please. We are five weeks from our wedding. Are you really going to let a domestic dispute become an investigation?”

He watched Arthur quietly close the correspondence tray.

“Where is the blue envelope Maria found?” Nicholas asked.

“What blue envelope?”

“The one you were looking for when you questioned her.”

“I have no idea what she's told you. You are rewarding her dishonesty.”

He wanted to ask her about the tablet, the false message, the scratch on her hand. Instead he said, “I will speak to you tomorrow, with the facts in front of us.”

After he hung up, he asked Gabriel to request an independent review of the foundation's recent transactions. Nicholas's criminal past and present gave him many ways to frighten a suspect. None of those ways would tell him whether a charity had lost money, or protect an innocent worker if his suspicion proved mistaken. For this, he wanted records that would survive questions from people who did not fear him.

Before midnight, the foundation's outside auditor, Clara Weston, agreed to come in the morning. She asked him to preserve the accounting system as it stood and not to warn anyone who might be involved in a transaction.

There was one more fact to establish. Nicholas called the woman who managed Eleanor House, a small respite center for families whose children were in long-term treatment. Eleanor had wanted such a place during her illness. It had opened after her death, and for years Nicholas had measured its success in ordinary things: a warm meal, an overnight room, a parent getting one uninterrupted hour of sleep.

Its director, Ruth Alden, sounded exhausted.

“I'm glad you called,” she said. “We've been trying to get an answer about the west wing.”

“What about it?”

“The renovation payments. Mr. Pike says the foundation has already advanced nearly half a million dollars. But no contractor has begun work, and we're being told to clear six family rooms before Saturday.”

Nicholas sat down slowly.

“Who told you to clear them?”

“Miss Hart's office. The notice says it's necessary before the benefit.”

Six rooms would mean six families moved, all for construction that apparently did not exist. Nicholas looked again at the empty place in his correspondence tray.

“Don't move anyone,” he said. “Not until you hear from me directly.”

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

Ruth exhaled. “Thank you. There's a mother downstairs with a child on oxygen. She was asking me where they were supposed to go.”

When the call ended, Nicholas understood that he was no longer investigating only what had happened to Lucy. He was investigating something that could reach far beyond his house.