Chapter 8 - The Courthouse Basement Had No Cameras

The county courthouse had cameras at every public entrance.

It had none in the old basement records corridor.

Susan's prepaid phone had connected briefly to a tower sector covering the courthouse complex, but that was not enough to pinpoint a room. State police swept the building. Local deputies were told only that they were assisting in a missing-person investigation.

Sheriff Kerr appeared personally.

Television cameras caught him entering through the front doors in uniform, jaw set, promising reporters that “every resource” would be used to find Susan Henderson.

I watched from the hotel television and felt sick.

“He knows we're looking at him,” I said.

Agent Ortiz nodded. “Assume he does.”

“Then why let him stand there?”

“Because suspicion isn't an arrest warrant.”

Tyler paced.

“My mother called from there.”

“We know.”

“He helped Dad.”

“We're investigating.”

“He could move her.”

Ortiz's expression sharpened. “Which is why you will not post anything, call anyone, or try to force his hand.”

Tyler looked away.

I knew that look.

He was going to do something stupid.

I waited until Ortiz left the room.

“What are you planning?”

“Nothing.”

“You're a terrible liar.”

“So is Dad. Didn't stop him.”

I stepped in front of him.

“If you go after Kerr, you could get Susan killed.”

He flinched.

Good.

Fear was better than recklessness.

That afternoon, Brooks returned with a courthouse maintenance map.

There was a disused tunnel connecting the courthouse basement to an annex that had once housed evidence storage. The tunnel had been sealed from the public side years ago but remained accessible through a keyed service door.

The sheriff's office controlled the key log.

One key had been checked out that morning.

By Daniel Kerr.

State police obtained a warrant.

The annex was mostly empty.

They found no Susan.

But they found her phone.

It lay smashed beneath a metal shelf.

They also found a folding chair with fresh blood on one armrest and strands of blond hair caught in a screw.

Susan's.

Tyler turned white when Brooks told us.

There was more.

A discarded bandage in a trash bin carried DNA from Susan and an unknown male.

And on the concrete floor, near the service door, investigators found a small brass object.

A key.

Not the key Susan had mentioned.

This one belonged to a motel.

Room 12, Pine Rest Motor Lodge.

Police reached the motel before sunset.

Room 12 was empty.

The bed had been slept in. Blood stained one pillow. A fast-food bag and two coffee cups sat on the table.

The clerk remembered Susan.

She had checked in alone around six that morning using cash.

Then, just before noon, a man in plain clothes showed a badge and asked which room she was in.

The clerk assumed he was police.

“Was it Kerr?” I asked.

The clerk had already looked at photographs.

No.

The man was younger.

About forty.

Dark hair.

Scar beside his left ear.

Brooks showed us the composite.

Tyler whispered, “I've seen him.”

“Where?”

“At Dad's office.”

“When?”

“A few times. He said his name was Wade.”

Naomi, who had joined us by video call, went still.

“Wade Mercer?”

Tyler shrugged. “Maybe.”

Naomi knew the name.

Wade Mercer had worked as a private investigator for Dad during the years Grandma first challenged the missing money. He had once been a county deputy.

Under Daniel Kerr.

The conspiracy was widening.

That evening, Brooks received another laboratory result from the lake house.

The broken picture frame beside Susan's blood held a photograph of Dad, Susan, and Tyler at a charity dinner.

Behind the photograph, folded into the backing, was a photocopy Susan had hidden.

It showed a bank transfer dated two days after my mother's crash.

$75,000 from Henderson Family Consulting to D. KERR CONSULTING.

Kerr had not formed that company until years later.

But the account number matched a personal account he had held in 2001.

It looked like a payoff.

Ortiz began preparing an arrest affidavit.

Then the state bureau's internal attorney called.

The payment alone was suspicious, not enough.

They needed a stronger link.

Grandma's ledger referenced the same transfer, but it was secondary evidence.

Mom's tape placed Dad at the house, not at the crash.

The original accident evidence was gone.

The vehicle had been destroyed decades ago.

The case still had holes.

I thought about Susan's words.

Claire had one thing Richard never found.

A key.

Martin knew.

“What if Martin didn't disappear?” I asked.

Brooks looked at me.

“What?”

“What if he ran?”

Naomi had said his car was found at the airport but there was no confirmed travel.

People had assumed he was dead because Dad frightened them.

But Grandma's recording never said she believed Martin was dead.

Only vanished.

Brooks searched the case file.

Martin Vale had a sister.

She lived in Oregon.

State police called her.

At first she refused to speak.

Then Brooks mentioned Margaret Henderson.

The woman began crying.

“My brother made me promise,” she said.

“Promise what?” Brooks asked.

“That if Margaret's granddaughter ever came looking, I would give her a name.”

I leaned toward the speaker.

“What name?”

The woman answered.

“Thomas Vail.”

Brooks typed it into a database.

A driver's license photograph appeared.

Older.

Gray beard.

Different glasses.

But I recognized the man from the Polaroid.

Martin Vale was alive.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

He had been living under another name for seventeen years.

And according to the address record, he lived less than four hours away.