Chapter 3 - The Answer in His Eyes

By late afternoon, the blizzard had swallowed the driveway. The estate's security vehicles stood under drifts of snow while a plow worked to keep the main approach open.
Lorenzo did not return to Manhattan. His study remained dark, his business calls unanswered, as he sat beside Giovanni in room 4B and waited for the physician.
Mrs. Gable delivered a folder of care records. The pages were neat, the entries regular, and every box seemed to report a comfortable patient receiving attentive treatment.
"He has been fed, washed, and monitored," she said. "Every procedure is documented."
Lorenzo turned to an entry dated the previous evening. "It says he ate salmon and steamed vegetables."
Nora looked up from the stool. "I brought him mashed potatoes and roasted chicken. There wasn't another meal."
Mrs. Gable's smile tightened. "The girl isn't aware of everything that happens in this house."
"No," Lorenzo said, closing the folder. "Apparently, neither am I."
The doctor arrived after sunset in a four-wheel-drive vehicle escorted by the estate's plow. Dr. Evelyn Hart was a neurologist from a neighboring hospital, summoned for an urgent independent assessment. Snow melted from her coat as she set her bag beside Giovanni's bed.
"I was told this gentleman has severe dementia," she said, looking at the summary Mrs. Gable had provided.
"That's what I've been told for five years," Lorenzo replied.
Dr. Hart examined Giovanni carefully. She did not promise a miracle. The old stroke had caused profound weakness and impaired his ability to speak. His muscles remained stiff, and his limited movement required specialized care.
But when she asked him to look toward the window and then toward the door, he followed her instructions.
"Mr. Moretti," she said to Giovanni, "I want you to look to your left for yes and to your right for no. We'll begin with something simple. Is your name Giovanni?"
His eyes moved left.
"Is your name Lorenzo?"
They moved right.
She repeated the questions in different order, waited between them, and tested his ability to follow instructions without Nora or Lorenzo prompting him.
The responses were slow but consistent enough to demand further evaluation.
"There is clear evidence of comprehension," Dr. Hart said. "That does not tell us everything about his cognition, and he needs formal speech-language and neuropsychological assessment. But it is absolutely wrong to assume he understands nothing merely because he cannot speak."
Lorenzo sat motionless.
He remembered every visit cut short because Giovanni seemed unresponsive. Every brief telephone update he had accepted. Every report saying there was no meaningful change.
"Could he have understood us all this time?"
"Quite possibly," Dr. Hart answered. "And we should have been trying to find out."
Nora watched Giovanni's eyes settle on her face. She had spoken to him about her daughter, her fears, and Brody because she could not bear the thought of anyone being left in silence. She had never known whether her words reached him.
Dr. Hart turned to her. "You've been caring for him?"
"When I could. I'm not a nurse."
"What did you notice?"
"He moves his fingers when I speak. Sometimes his eyes follow me. Once, when I told him my baby's name, he cried."
"Those observations matter," Dr. Hart said. "So does the fact that you treated him as a person."
She checked Giovanni's skin, hydration, muscle contractures, and wheelchair fit. She found signs of inadequate turning and hygiene. He needed a proper pressure-relieving chair, a swallowing assessment, a regular repositioning schedule, and a qualified care team.
"I cannot determine every cause of this neglect from one examination," she told Lorenzo. "But his living conditions have been unacceptable."
Mrs. Gable stood near the door. "He's always refused strangers. That's why we use familiar staff."
Dr. Hart looked at Giovanni. "He may have preferences. We can ask him through supported communication instead of guessing."
She pointed to the door. "Would you like Mrs. Gable to stay while we examine you? Left for yes, right for no."
Giovanni's gaze moved decisively right.
Mrs. Gable's mouth opened.
"That is not a complete assessment," Dr. Hart said calmly. "But I will respect the answer while we continue. Please wait outside."
After the door closed, Lorenzo bowed his head. He could not claim ignorance anymore. His father's mind had not disappeared simply because his voice had.
Nora shifted on the stool. A tight sensation passed across her lower abdomen. She put one hand on her belly until it eased.
Dr. Hart noticed. "Have you had prenatal care?"
"At a clinic. They told me to avoid heavy lifting."
"And have you been avoiding it?"
Nora glanced at Lorenzo. His expression provided the answer.
"I'm arranging a maternity assessment tonight," he said.
"Ask her first," Dr. Hart replied.
That small correction made Lorenzo pause. He turned toward Nora.
"Would you agree to an examination?"
"Yes," she said. "I would."
A nurse from the physician's visiting team checked Nora's blood pressure, symptoms, and fetal movement in a separate sitting room. She advised rest and urged prompt hospital evaluation for any warning signs or regular contractions. Nora listened carefully, frightened by how close Lily's birth had come.
Meanwhile, Lorenzo ordered the kitchen to prepare Giovanni's evening meal according to the doctor's swallowing precautions. A care aide, trained in patient transfers, was assigned to remain with him. The room was made properly warm, not merely staged to look pleasant.
Later that night, Rosa, a kitchen maid who had worked at the estate longer than Nora, appeared outside Lorenzo's study.
"Sir, I didn't know who else to tell," she said, twisting her apron. "The records Mrs. Gable brought you are new."
Lorenzo looked up. "What do you mean?"
"She made us fill them in this morning. She said if anyone wrote down the meals we really served, she'd dismiss us all."
"Did you write anything?"
"I wrote the truth on scraps before. I kept some because I was afraid they'd blame me when the food came back untouched."
She took a folded page from her pocket. Its dates went back several weeks. Next to Giovanni's name were notes about trays left in the corridor, meals returned cold, and nights when the east wing's heat had been turned down.
The signatures on the official folder reported that Giovanni had eaten full meals on those same days.
Lorenzo laid the two records side by side.
One had been made to describe care.
The other had been made to conceal its absence.
"Bring me every scrap you kept," he said quietly.
Rosa nodded, but she did not leave immediately.
"There's something else. Mrs. Gable always told us the private nurses had already visited. But I work the morning and evening shifts. I haven't seen a private nurse in this house for more than a year."
Lorenzo looked from the falsified sheets to the invoices stacked beside them.
May you like
Every month, the family accounts had paid a substantial sum for Giovanni's private nursing service.
And now Lorenzo had to discover where that money had gone.