Chapter 2 - Smoke Rising From the Study He Kept Locked

The fire never reached the roof.

It looked worse from outside because Robert had shoved papers into the study fireplace faster than the chimney could draw. Smoke rolled through the second floor, triggering alarms and sending the twins crying into the yard in their pajamas.

Eleanor's driver had already called emergency services.

Robert hated that.

By the time firefighters entered the house, he was standing in the snow with soot on one sleeve and fury in his eyes.

“I was burning old records,” he said. “In my own fireplace.”

A firefighter glanced at the black smoke pouring from the study window.

“At midnight on Christmas?”

Robert did not answer.

I watched from inside the greenhouse doorway, wrapped in my mother's coat and holding her letter beneath it. My hands had finally begun to hurt as feeling returned to them.

Ethan came toward me.

“What was down there?”

I studied him.

An hour earlier he had laughed while telling me Dad had declined Hawthorne for me. Now his face looked younger than sixteen.

“Things Mom left.”

He swallowed. “Your mom?”

“Yes.”

He looked toward Robert.

“I didn't know there was a cellar.”

“Neither did I.”

That seemed to frighten him more than anything else.

Police arrived with the fire department because Eleanor's security team reported possible destruction of trust records. Robert immediately demanded a lawyer. Karen began insisting she knew nothing about the study fire, then became furious when an officer asked whether Robert had removed documents before the firefighters came.

“I was getting the children out,” she snapped.

The officer wrote that down.

Inside, the study smelled like wet ash and scorched leather. Water streaked the floorboards. Most of the fire had been contained inside the fireplace and the rug directly in front of it.

Robert had not had enough time.

A metal cash box sat open beside his desk.

Empty.

Eleanor's attorney, a woman named Mara Keene, arrived before one in the morning wearing boots over a dark business suit. She looked at the room once and said, “Nobody touches anything until the police finish documenting it.”

Robert laughed bitterly.

“You brought a lawyer to Christmas?”

“I brought three,” Eleanor replied.

Mara glanced at me. “Emily, you're eighteen now?”

“Not yet. Twelve minutes.”

She checked her watch.

“Then we wait twelve minutes before you sign anything.”

That tiny act—someone caring whether I understood what I signed—nearly broke me.

While officers photographed the study, I noticed a wet corner of paper beneath the desk. One edge had escaped the flames.

I pointed it out instead of touching it.

An officer used gloves to lift it.

Most of the page was charred, but a line near the bottom remained readable.

R. CASTER — ACCOUNT 7714.

My father saw it from across the room.

His face changed.

Mara saw that too.

“Caster?” I asked.

Robert stared at me.

“It's nothing.”

Eleanor's eyes moved to him. “Laura wrote about a second surname.”

The room went silent.

Robert turned on her. “You poisoned her against me.”

“No,” Eleanor said. “She was afraid of you before she ever called me.”

Karen stepped closer to the burned page.

“What account?”

He ignored her.

That was the second crack between them.

At midnight, my phone was still locked inside Robert's desk drawer. An officer found it while photographing the room and handed it to me.

The screen lit with dozens of missed notifications.

Messages from classmates.

A birthday reminder.

Three emails from Hawthorne Preparatory Academy.

The newest had been sent two days earlier.

SUBJECT: CONFIRMATION OF WITHDRAWAL REQUEST.

My stomach dropped.

I opened it.

Dear Emily, we are sorry to hear you will not be joining our incoming program. As requested in your email, your scholarship will be released to the next candidate unless we hear otherwise by December 26.

I had never sent that request.

Mara leaned over my shoulder.

“Can you show me the sent message?”

I opened my email account.

There it was.

Sent three days earlier from my address.

I read the words aloud.

I have reconsidered and do not wish to attend. Please do not contact me again.

The message had been sent at 2:13 p.m.

I knew exactly where I had been at 2:13.

At school.

In ceramics class.

My phone had been at home because Robert had grounded me for “attitude.”

Ethan stared at the screen.

“Dad had your phone that day.”

Robert said nothing.

I looked at him.

“Did you send this?”

“You were making a childish decision.”

“That isn't an answer.”

“I am your father.”

“I'm eighteen.”

For the first time, saying it felt real.

Mara took a slow breath. “Emily, don't delete anything. We'll preserve the account data.”

Robert's expression hardened.

“You think an email matters compared with what she's planning?” He pointed at Eleanor. “She wants the estate. She always has.”

Eleanor's voice stayed calm.

“The estate already belongs to Emily.”

Karen turned toward Robert.

“What does that mean for us?”

He looked at her, then at the burned study, then at the police.

And I finally saw what my mother had understood years ago.

When Robert lost control of one person, he immediately looked for another thing to control.

His gaze settled on Ethan.

“Get your coat,” he said.

Ethan did not move.

“Why?”

Robert's eyes narrowed.

“Because we're leaving.”

Ethan looked at me.

Then he looked at the burned page on the evidence tray.

“No,” he said.

The word was barely louder than a whisper.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

But Robert heard it.

So did everyone else.