Chapter 14 - The Deposition Notice Forced Natalie to Choose Precision Over Anger

The legal notice looked more dramatic than it was.

Academy counsel explained that Richard’s attorney was preserving evidence for an employment appeal and possible wrongful-termination claim. Natalie had not yet been subpoenaed. No lawsuit had been filed. Still, every message, email, photo, and note connected to the matter now had to be retained.

Natalie laughed once when the attorney finished explaining.

“Good thing I was already keeping everything.”

“Yes,” counsel said. “Your instinct to document rather than argue has served you well.”

Natalie thought of all the times Richard had accused her of being cold, rigid, overly serious.

The traits he mocked were now protecting her.

She spent the afternoon creating a chronology with counsel.

The graduation invitation.

The ticket taken from her hand.

Richard’s comments about Brianna meeting generals.

The shove in the rain.

The attempted access request.

Brianna’s statement about the attendee list.

The anonymous compliance contact.

The slide deck.

The old email from Brianna.

Richard’s memo.

His voicemails.

Each event alone could have been minimized. Together, they formed a pattern too coherent to dismiss as misunderstanding.

At the end, counsel asked, “Do you want to make any correction to your prior statements?”

Natalie thought carefully.

“Yes.”

The attorney looked up.

“I said earlier that my father did not understand my work. That was my belief at the time. The documents show he did understand its significance. I want the record to distinguish what I believed from what I now know.”

The attorney smiled faintly. “That distinction is exactly why witnesses should avoid guessing.”

Natalie left feeling steadier.

Outside, Brianna waited with two coffees and a notebook labeled BUDGET in large letters.

“You’re serious?” Natalie asked.

“You said you’d help.”

“I did.”

They sat beneath a tree on the edge of the quad.

Brianna’s finances were worse than Natalie expected. Brand deals came irregularly. Richard had paid her car insurance, phone plan, and part of her rent. Vanessa had covered emergencies. Brianna had built a public image of independence on top of a private structure she did not control.

“This is humiliating,” she muttered.

“No, this is arithmetic.”

“Arithmetic can be humiliating.”

Natalie almost smiled.

They reduced expenses. Brianna agreed to sell a designer handbag she rarely used and contact a former photography client about steady editing work. Natalie helped her compare health insurance options without offering to pay them.

Halfway through, Brianna said, “You know what’s weird?”

“Many things.”

“I’m less scared than I thought I’d be.”

“About money?”

“About Dad being mad.”

Natalie stopped writing.

Brianna stared at her notebook.

“I always thought if he stopped approving of me, I’d have nothing. But he stopped, and I still woke up this morning.”

Natalie knew exactly what she meant.

That evening, Vanessa appeared at the academy visitor center alone.

Natalie agreed to see her.

Vanessa looked immaculate as always, but there were dark circles beneath her eyes.

“Richard is talking about suing Harrow,” she said.

“I heard.”

“He thinks they needed a scapegoat.”

“Do you?”

Vanessa looked away.

Natalie waited.

“I think Thomas encouraged things he should not have encouraged.”

“That is not what I asked.”

Vanessa’s mouth tightened.

“No. I don’t think Richard is innocent.”

It was the first time Natalie had heard her say anything close to that.

“Then why are you here?”

“Because he is still your father.”

Natalie leaned back.

There it was, the family’s oldest argument.

Vanessa surprised her by continuing.

“And because I helped create this.”

Natalie said nothing.

“I let him dismiss you. I defended him because it was easier than confronting him. I told myself you were strong and Brianna was sensitive, so you could take more.” Vanessa swallowed. “That was convenient for me.”

Natalie’s anger did not disappear. But it shifted.

“Why tell me now?”

“Because Brianna moved out this morning.”

Natalie blinked.

“She what?”

“She took her things. She said she needs to learn how to live without asking us whether she is allowed.”

A strange pride rose in Natalie.

Vanessa looked toward the door.

“Your father thinks you turned her against us.”

“No. She made a decision.”

“I know.” Vanessa’s eyes filled. “That may be what frightens him most.”

Before leaving, Vanessa placed a small envelope on the table.

“I found this in Richard’s desk after he was fired.”

Natalie opened it.

Inside was a handwritten letter addressed to Richard from General Ellison, dated three months earlier.

The first line read:

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

Your daughter has distinguished herself in ways any parent should be proud to understand before graduation day.

Natalie traced Ellison’s signature with one finger. The letter was not sentimental. It praised discipline, intellectual courage, and the way she had supported struggling cadets without lowering standards. Those were exactly the qualities Richard had claimed no one outside the family would notice. Vanessa watched her read and seemed to understand why the page hurt. Richard had not merely missed a signal. Someone had placed the truth directly in his hands three months before graduation, and he had folded it into a desk drawer where Natalie could not see that she had already been seen.