Chapter 4 - The Life in the Photograph

I returned to the hospital the following afternoon carrying the oldest envelope from the suitcase. Lucas had let me take it home after Douglas fell asleep, but I hadn't opened it.

All night, it had rested on the table beside my bed.

I had imagined those words for forty-one years. Now that they were real, I discovered I was afraid to read them.

Lucas was waiting in the family sitting area with a photograph in his hand.

"This is the one I mentioned," he said.

He handed it to me without ceremony.

Douglas stood outside a modest house, looking younger than he had in my memories of the summer of 1986. Beside him was Evelyn, dark-haired and smiling, holding a baby wrapped in a pale blanket. Their shoulders touched. Both looked tired, but there was unmistakable happiness in their expressions.

"That's you?" I asked.

"That's me. A few weeks old."

I studied Evelyn's face. For years, she had existed only as the unnamed woman who received the future I had once imagined. Seeing her now made that old comparison feel unfair to someone who hadn't known I was making it.

"She's beautiful," I said.

"She was."

Lucas sat beside me.

"She taught school. She liked people who told the truth, even when it made life complicated. Dad said that was one reason he loved her."

I continued holding the picture.

"Did she know about me?"

"Not at first. Eventually, yes. Dad told her there had been someone he cared for before they married. He didn't tell her every detail right away. That caused trouble."

"I can imagine."

"She asked him whether he intended to keep looking backward or build a life with the person standing beside him."

I thought of that question for a long moment.

"And what did he say?"

"He chose to stay. Every day that counted."

Lucas didn't say his father had forgotten me. He didn't need to. There was a difference between remembering another person and abandoning the one who shared your home. I had spent decades assuming Douglas had left me because I wasn't enough. I now saw that Evelyn had lived with a different uncertainty: whether some part of her husband's heart would always belong to a memory.

"Was your mother happy?" I asked.

"Not every day," Lucas said. "Nobody is. But she loved her family, and she knew she was loved. I won't pretend they had a perfect marriage. I won't pretend it was empty, either."

I handed the photograph back.

"You don't have to pretend anything for me."

He slipped it carefully into an envelope.

"Thank you."

We sat for a while without speaking. Then Lucas noticed the letter in my hand.

"Is that one of Dad's?"

I nodded.

"One of the oldest. From the years when I still expected his letters."

"Are you going to open it?"

"I think so. I wanted to do it where I could ask him questions."

Lucas looked toward the corridor leading to his father's room.

"He's awake."

Douglas was propped against his pillows when we entered. The suitcase had been closed and placed beside the chair. He looked exhausted, but his eyes brightened when he saw me.

"Ruthie."

I hadn't heard the name in years, and now it seemed to follow me everywhere I went.

"I brought something," I told him.

His gaze dropped to the envelope.

"I wondered whether you'd read that one."

I sat and opened it slowly. Inside was one sheet, folded into thirds.

It was addressed to me on my twentieth birthday.

Douglas had written about the distance between us, his first months away, the strange feeling of making new friends while missing the person who knew him best. He hadn't declared undying love. He had simply described a wish that I could have been there to see the ordinary parts of his new life.

At the bottom, a sentence made me stop.

I hope there will be a day when I am brave enough to tell you why I keep starting letters like this.

"You wrote that before the last letter," I said.

"Yes."

"Before you knew about Lucas."

"Long before."

I looked at the handwriting. His fear hadn't begun with Evelyn or an impending marriage. It had begun when we were young enough to believe every difficult feeling could be postponed.

"We were both frightened," I said.

Douglas's mouth moved into a sad smile.

"We were."

"But I need you to understand something. Our fear when we were nineteen isn't the same as what happened later. You made a decision for both of us when you told me never to contact you."

"I know."

"You keep saying that."

"Because it's true. I don't have a better defense."

The directness of his answer unsettled me more than an excuse would have. I had rehearsed arguments against every possible justification. He wasn't giving me one.

I folded the letter and placed it beside the ring box.

"Why did you keep writing every year?"

He looked toward the window.

"At first I thought I could put things in words and finally let them go. Then I realized writing them was a way to remember a person who had made me feel understood when I was young. I never intended them to be proof that you belonged to me."

"But you hoped I'd see them someday."

He was silent long enough for the pause to become an answer.

"Some part of me did," he admitted.

Lucas moved the water glass closer to his father. Douglas drank a little and returned it.

"When Evelyn was alive, did she know about the birthday letters?" I asked.

"She found some years ago," he said. "I told her what they were. We had a difficult conversation. She deserved that honesty much earlier."

"And she stayed?"

"Yes. But she made me understand that remembering you could not be an excuse for withholding myself from her. She was right."

I thought of the photograph: Evelyn holding her newborn son, Douglas beside her, both of them exhausted and smiling. I couldn't resent that young family. I could resent what Douglas had done to me without needing their happiness to have been false.

A nurse interrupted to check his blood pressure. Douglas answered her questions, and I watched how much energy the exchange required.

When she left, I stood to go. He reached out, then stopped before touching my hand.

"Will you come back?"

I looked at the ring, the letters, and the man who had once been my entire idea of the future.

"Yes," I said. "But not because you bought a ring. And not because I'm meant to make these years come out differently."

"Why, then?"

"Because we're talking now. And I don't want another important conversation to end simply because one of us is afraid."

Lucas walked me to the doorway.

"Dad asked me to tell you something earlier," he said quietly. "He wants to show you the one letter he nearly sent after he married Mom."

I looked toward the closed suitcase.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

The old letters were beginning to tell me what Douglas had felt.

The next one, I suspected, would show me what he had almost done.