Chapter 8 - Carter Finally Admitted Why My Name Was Chosen for the Crime

Carter lasted six hours in custody before asking for a lawyer and eight more before deciding the lawyer Nolan had recommended was probably working for Nolan.

Then he asked to speak with me.

Mara refused at first. Lena argued that any contact should be monitored and voluntary. I agreed because I wanted one answer more than I wanted revenge.

Why me?

Carter sat behind a metal table in a federal interview room, his expensive haircut flattened, his confidence gone. For years he had treated me like a rival born into advantages he wanted. Now he looked younger than his thirty-two years.

“I didn't plan for you to go to prison,” he began.

I laughed once.

“Try again.”

He stared at his hands.

His gambling started small—sports bets, private poker rooms, then credit extended by people who did not send polite collection notices. By the time Reagan learned, he owed hundreds of thousands. Nolan approached him with a solution: create temporary vendor accounts inside Dennis Architectural Metals and skim enough to settle the debt.

Carter had access but not authority.

I had authority because Camden was training me to oversee procurement.

So Nolan copied my access token.

At first, Carter believed the transfers would be hidden among legitimate expenses and repaid. Then Victor Saye expanded the scheme. Millions moved through shell companies. When an internal review became unavoidable, Nolan said they needed a single employee whose access history could explain everything.

My name was already inside the system.

“You let them build the case,” I said.

“Yes.”

“You testified that I asked you for money after the theft.”

“Yes.”

“You watched Dad stop speaking to me.”

Carter's face crumpled, but I felt no urge to comfort him.

“Nolan said if I backed out, he'd give the lenders my mother's address.”

“You still chose.”

He nodded.

That was the difference between explanation and excuse.

Carter also admitted something Reagan did not know. Camden's illness began after Nolan introduced Dr. Samuel Keene as a private physician. Keene prescribed medication for anxiety and insomnia. Carter once saw Nolan replace a bottle in Camden's bathroom with another that had the same label.

“What was in it?” Mara asked through the intercom.

“I don't know.”

“Where is Keene?”

“Nolan said Mexico. I think that's a lie.”

Then Carter explained the staged desert transfer. Nolan had called him after Reagan met me. He threatened to expose Carter to Victor unless Carter followed instructions. Carter was told to drive to Red Mesa and escort a patient to the airstrip. He believed the patient was Camden until agents opened the van.

“Nolan used me to pull everyone away,” he said.

“From where?”

Carter hesitated.

“There is another property.”

The room changed.

He described a house near Big Bear that Victor used for private card games years earlier. Nolan called it Coldwater. Carter had never been inside, but he once delivered medication there after Camden left Harbor Point.

“Was Dad there?”

“I heard his voice.”

My body went rigid.

“When?”

“Four months ago.”

Carter gave Mara directions from memory: a forest road, a green gate, a stone chimney visible above the trees.

Agents began checking property records immediately.

Before he was taken away, Carter stopped at the door.

“Finnley.”

I looked at him.

“I know sorry doesn't do anything.”

“No. It doesn't.”

“But there is one thing you should know. Your father never stopped trying to clear you. Even at Harbor Point, he kept asking me to tell the truth. He said he'd forgive the money if I told them you didn't do it.”

That hurt more than I expected.

“Why didn't you?”

Carter's answer was almost inaudible.

“Because I was a coward.”

After he left, Mara's team identified three properties matching his description. One belonged to a trust connected to Victor Saye.

The house had no active utilities under its address, but thermal satellite data from a recent wildfire survey showed consistent heat use.

Someone was living there.

Mara ordered a quiet approach before dawn.

This time I did not argue when she told me to stay behind.

At 5:17 a.m., my phone rang.

Mara did not speak first.

I heard movement, voices, a door opening somewhere far away.

Then another voice came through the line.

Weak. Breathless. Familiar.

“Finnley?”

For three years I had imagined my father saying my name again.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

When it finally happened, I could not answer.

Before Mara ended the interview, she asked Carter to draw every route he remembered to Coldwater. He marked a gas station, a washed-out turnout, and a bend where the road passed an abandoned ranger shed. His hand shook so badly that the lines wandered across the page. Still, agents matched the landmarks to county maps. For once, something Carter gave us was useful because it was specific enough to test rather than merely convenient to believe.