Chapter 4 - The Brother Who Refused to Stay Dead

Eleanor climbed the basement stairs before anyone could stop her.

Thomas caught her wrist.

"No."

She pulled free.

"He is my brother."

"He may have killed Samuel Reed."

"He may have done worse."

"Exactly."

Eleanor looked at him.

"For fifty years, everyone decided what I should know. That ends now."

Thomas stared at her for a moment.

Then nodded.

"Then I'm coming."

Daniel whispered, "He wants that."

Clara said, "So do I."

Eleanor turned.

"No."

"Grandma."

"No."

Clara's expression hardened.

"You don't get to spend an hour lecturing everyone about secrecy and then send me away."

Thomas almost smiled.

Eleanor pointed at her.

"This is different."

"It always is when you're the person keeping the secret."

That silenced her.

Daniel said, "We go together."

They climbed.

Michael Carter stood in the burned warehouse with a cane in one hand and a revolver in the other.

At seventy-five, he still had the Carter eyes.

Eleanor hated that first.

The familiarity.

The way his left eyebrow lifted when he was amused.

The same way their father had looked across the dinner table.

Michael smiled.

"Ellie."

"Don't."

He looked at Thomas.

"And the dead return."

Thomas's voice was flat.

"You would know."

Michael laughed.

"Still dramatic."

"Where is Rebecca?"

"Safe."

"That word has been abused enough today."

Michael's smile faded.

Daniel stepped forward.

"Marcus is working for you."

Michael glanced at him.

"Marcus works for whoever pays."

"So yes."

"Today."

Eleanor stared at her brother.

"You attended David's funeral."

Michael looked back at her.

"I wanted to see you."

"You let me think you were dead for fifty-six years."

"Our father let you think that."

"You chose it."

"At nineteen, choices are rarely clean."

Thomas muttered, "Some of us learned that."

Michael looked at him.

"Still carrying your martyrdom?"

Thomas stepped closer.

"You put Samuel Reed in my truck."

Michael's eyes sharpened.

"Did Peter tell you that?"

"His son did."

Michael looked at Daniel with contempt.

"Your father was weak."

Daniel replied, "And you're standing in a burned warehouse pointing a gun at your sister. I don't think you should lecture anyone."

Clara whispered, "Good point."

Michael glanced at her.

"And you must be Clara."

Eleanor moved between them.

"Do not say her name."

"I know a great deal about your family."

"That is not comforting."

"It wasn't meant to be."

Eleanor took a step.

"Where is Rebecca?"

Michael studied her.

"Why do you care?"

"Because Thomas does."

A flicker crossed his face.

There.

Jealousy.

After fifty years.

Eleanor saw it and suddenly understood more than she wanted.

"This was always about Thomas."

Michael laughed.

"No."

"You hated him."

"I hated what he made you willing to throw away."

"What?"

"Us."

"Our family?"

"Our father. The store. The land. Your future."

"My future was mine."

"You were going to marry a Bell."

"Yes."

"You don't understand what that meant."

"Then explain it."

Michael's face hardened.

"The Bells were going to destroy us."

Thomas laughed.

"My father owned a farm."

"Your father owned the ridge."

Daniel said, "The mineral rights."

Michael looked at him.

"Not lithium. Not then. Limestone, timber, water access, future highway frontage. Harold had spent twenty years buying around it. Thomas marrying Eleanor would have joined the parcels."

Eleanor stared.

"You thought I was a business deal?"

"No. Harold did."

"My father wanted me to marry Thomas?"

Michael smiled bitterly.

"He changed his mind."

"Why?"

"Because he discovered Thomas's father had put the farm entirely in Thomas's name."

Thomas frowned.

"My father didn't tell me that."

"He was going to."

Eleanor said, "So what?"

"So Harold realized a marriage would put you in a stronger position than me."

Silence.

Clara whispered, "Inheritance."

Michael looked at her.

"Smart girl."

Eleanor's voice went cold.

"You were afraid Daddy would leave me the business."

"He planned to."

"So you stole deeds."

"I protected what should have been mine."

"You were nineteen."

"I was his son."

"And I was his daughter."

Michael's face twisted.

"Exactly."

The word told her everything.

Eleanor felt an old childhood return.

Michael getting the larger room.

Michael told to learn the business.

Eleanor told she would marry well.

But her father had changed.

Maybe too late.

Maybe enough for Michael to notice.

Thomas asked, "Samuel?"

Michael looked at him.

"Samuel found the forged deeds."

"And you killed him."

"I didn't intend to."

Eleanor's throat tightened.

Michael continued, almost calmly.

"He demanded money. We argued. He fell."

"Fell where?"

"Loading platform."

Clara whispered, "You could have called an ambulance."

Michael's jaw tightened.

"He was dead."

"So you put him in Thomas's truck."

"Peter helped."

Daniel shook his head.

"My father said he didn't."

"Your father lied every time fear touched him."

Thomas stepped forward.

"Did Peter help?"

Michael smiled.

"No."

Daniel exhaled.

Eleanor looked at him.

Michael continued.

"Peter discovered me loading the body. We fought. I shot him in the shoulder."

Thomas's fists clenched.

"With my father's gun."

"Yes."

"You planted it in my truck."

"Yes."

"And Peter blamed me."

"Because I told him if he didn't, I would tell police he killed Samuel."

Daniel whispered, "He was nineteen too."

Michael glanced at him.

"Twenty-one."

Thomas asked, "The crash?"

"I drove your truck."

"With Samuel inside."

"Yes."

"You pushed it over Miller's Ridge."

"Yes."

Eleanor felt nauseated.

"The dental records."

"Marcus's father worked for the county coroner."

Daniel closed his eyes.

"Generational corruption. Wonderful."

Michael ignored him.

Thomas said, "Then why was I paid to leave?"

"Because you were inconveniently alive."

"You knew I was in jail."

"I knew exactly where you were."

Eleanor whispered, "You forged Daddy's note."

"Yes."

"And lied that I was pregnant."

Michael looked at her.

"You would have followed him otherwise."

"I loved him."

"At twenty-two."

"I loved him."

"You survived."

The sentence enraged her.

"You don't get credit for what I survived."

Michael's grip tightened on the revolver.

"I saved you from a Bell."

Thomas laughed.

"You turned her life into a decision she never made."

Michael looked at him.

"And what did you do? Took the money."

Thomas flinched.

Eleanor saw it.

Michael continued.

"You believed she was carrying your child and still disappeared."

Thomas said quietly, "I was a coward."

Eleanor looked at him.

He did not look away.

"I was."

Michael seemed annoyed that the accusation failed.

He turned back to Eleanor.

"You married David Hayes. Good man. Two children. A stable life."

"One child."

Michael blinked.

"What?"

"My son died at birth."

His face changed.

He had not known.

Eleanor's eyes filled.

"David and I had one surviving daughter. Clara's mother."

Michael lowered the gun slightly.

"I didn't know."

"Because you were dead."

The words landed.

For the first time, her brother looked old.

Clara asked, "Where is Rebecca?"

Michael looked at her.

"Marcus moved her."

"Where?"

"Bell farm."

Thomas took a step.

Michael raised the gun again.

"No."

Eleanor whispered, "Why?"

"Because we have one final problem."

"The will."

"Not the will."

"What?"

Michael looked at Daniel.

"Peter's journal."

Daniel's face tightened.

Michael continued.

"Harold Carter discovered the truth in 1979. He wrote everything down."

Eleanor whispered, "Daddy knew you killed Samuel."

"Eventually."

"Why didn't he go to police?"

Michael smiled sadly.

"Because I was his son."

Eleanor closed her eyes.

Of course.

Even truth had limits.

Michael said, "He tried to make me surrender the deeds. I threatened to expose his role in Thomas's disappearance."

"But he didn't have a role."

"He believed he did."

Thomas frowned.

"How?"

"I used his account."

"The payment."

"Yes."

"If police investigated, Harold looked involved."

Eleanor asked, "What did he do?"

"He began keeping a journal."

"And Peter got it."

"After Harold died."

Thomas asked, "Where is it?"

"At Bell farm."

Daniel said, "I don't know where."

Michael looked at him.

"Your father did."

"My father is dead."

"Then we search."

Eleanor stared.

"You kidnapped Rebecca to force Thomas to bring the will, and you lured Daniel here for a journal."

Michael nodded.

"Once the sale closes, none of this matters."

"It matters to Samuel's family."

"They're dead."

"It matters to Thomas."

"He survived."

"It matters to me."

Michael looked at her.

"Why? What changes?"

Eleanor stepped closer until only several feet separated them.

"My father lied. My brother became a murderer. Thomas lived. Peter spent his life afraid. Samuel died without a grave. Everything changes."

Michael whispered, "Not the years."

"No."

"Then why destroy what's left?"

"Because the years are already gone."

Sirens sounded faintly in the distance.

Michael looked toward the door.

Daniel smiled.

"Ben."

Michael's face changed.

"You called police."

Clara held up her phone.

"Pocket dial."

Eleanor almost laughed.

Michael raised the gun toward Clara.

Thomas moved.

So did Eleanor.

The gun fired.

Thomas fell.

Eleanor screamed.

Michael stared at him.

"I didn't—"

Eleanor dropped beside Thomas.

Blood spread across his upper arm.

"Thomas."

"I'm okay."

"You were shot."

"Shoulder."

"You always were terrible at definitions."

Police shouted outside.

Michael backed away.

Clara grabbed the fallen cane.

Daniel moved toward the door.

Michael lifted the gun again.

Eleanor stood between him and Thomas.

"Put it down."

"Ellie."

"Put it down."

"You don't understand."

"No. I finally do."

"What?"

"You never protected me."

Michael's eyes filled.

"You protected the version of the family where you mattered most."

The gun trembled.

Eleanor continued.

"Daddy chose silence. Peter chose fear. Thomas chose disappearance. You chose control."

She looked down at Thomas.

"And I spent fifty years living inside all of your choices."

Michael whispered, "I'm sorry."

"Then stop choosing for me."

His hand lowered.

Police entered.

Ben shouted.

"Gun down!"

Michael let it fall.

The revolver hit the concrete.

Thomas, pale but conscious, looked at Eleanor.

She knelt beside him again.

"Rebecca," he whispered.

Eleanor took his hand.

"We're going to the farm."

Ben said, "You're going to the hospital."

Thomas shook his head.

Eleanor squeezed his hand hard.

"Hospital first."

He looked at her.

"Still bossy."

May you like

[COMPLETED] She waited ten years for her fiancé, but the night she marri...

[COMPLETED] Five Years After My Mafia Husband Chose Another Woman, He Me...

[COMPLETED] I CALLED MY HUSBAND 18 TIMES WHILE OUR SON WAS DYING. EIGHT...

She almost smiled.

"Some things haven't changed."