Chapter 6 - The Third Pew

The abandoned chapel at St. Agnes stood behind chain-link fencing and a row of dead maple trees.

Its windows had been boarded from the inside. The roof sagged near the bell tower. Someone had spray-painted a red crown across the front doors.

Mara studied the fence.

“Elsie came here alone?”

Owen held up a pair of bolt cutters.

“Probably.”

Claire stared at him.

“Why do you own those?”

“Journalism.”

“That is not an answer.”

“It is in my field.”

Naomi had stayed behind to file for access to St. Orison's archived records. Lucas was meeting Helena at the Vale estate.

That left Claire, Mara and Owen to follow Ruth's clue.

Inside, the chapel smelled of dust, mold and old wood.

Sunlight entered through cracks in the boards and laid thin white lines across the floor.

The pews were still in place.

Mara counted.

“One. Two. Three.”

They knelt beside the third pew.

Nothing looked unusual.

Claire ran her fingers beneath the seat.

“Little brass bird.”

Owen crouched near the aisle.

“There.”

A tiny brass swallow had been nailed to the underside of the pew.

Mara touched it.

“It moves.”

The bird twisted sideways.

A narrow panel opened in the wood.

Inside was a plastic envelope.

Claire's heart slammed.

Mara pulled it free.

The envelope contained a flash drive, a Polaroid photograph and a handwritten note.

The Polaroid showed Elsie standing beside an older woman in a wheelchair.

Claire knew the woman immediately.

Not because she remembered her face.

Because she had drawn that face herself as a child.

A long nose. Dark eyes. A deep dimple in the left cheek.

“Our mother,” she whispered.

Mara sat down hard on the floor.

“Oh my God.”

On the back, Elsie had written:

Mara, I found her. Her name is Ruth. She remembers everything. H moved her before I could get her out. If I disappear, the drive has the first transfer route. Trust Owen. Be careful with Lucas. He knows less than his mother, but more than Claire.

Claire read the last line twice.

Owen watched her.

“She didn't know he had seen the file.”

“She knew enough.”

Mara took the flash drive.

“Let's see what's on it.”

Owen opened his laptop.

The first folder contained scanned documents from St. Orison. The second held audio recordings. The third was labeled TRANSFERS.

Mara clicked it.

A spreadsheet appeared.

Jane Ruth Bellamy — discharge to Vale Private Care, May 18.

Destination: Rosemere Cottage.

Claire stared at the address.

“Where is that?”

Owen searched offline maps.

“Property belongs to a holding company.”

“Which one?”

He zoomed in.

“Vale Heritage LLC.”

Mara stood.

“We go now.”

Owen held up one hand.

“Wait.”

She rounded on him.

“What?”

“If Helena moved Ruth there, it may be watched.”

“Then we call police.”

“With what allegation? An adult woman discharged to private care?”

“She was held under false guardianship.”

“We're building that case. We don't have it yet.”

Mara slammed the pew with her palm.

“So we do nothing?”

Claire took the flash drive.

“We verify first.”

Mara stared at her.

“You sound like Lucas.”

Claire flinched.

“That's unfair.”

“Is it?”

“Yes.”

Mara paced toward the altar.

“Elsie is missing. Mom was moved by Helena. Every time we wait, someone else decides where our family goes.”

Claire followed.

“I am not asking you to wait days. I am asking you to wait twenty minutes while Owen checks whether Rosemere has cameras, security or another exit.”

Mara looked away.

Claire lowered her voice.

“I know you had to survive by moving before anyone could stop you.”

Mara looked back sharply.

“Don't analyze me.”

“I'm not.”

“You are.”

“I am trying to understand my sister.”

The anger in Mara's face wavered.

Claire continued.

“I don't want to lose Elsie because we rush into the same people who took her.”

Mara swallowed.

“Fine. Twenty minutes.”

Owen quietly began working.

Claire opened the audio folder.

One file was dated three weeks earlier.

Elsie's voice came through first.

“Tell me your name.”

A weaker voice answered.

“Ruth Bell.”

Mara gripped Claire's arm.

Elsie asked, “How many daughters do you have?”

“Three.”

“Their names?”

“Mara. Claire. Elsie.”

Ruth began to cry.

“I named you after my grandmother. You hated it.”

Elsie laughed through tears on the recording.

“I still kind of do.”

Claire covered her mouth.

Ruth continued.

“Mara had a chipped front tooth. Claire had a scar from the birdbath. Elsie bit Dr. Sloane.”

Mara whispered, “She remembers.”

Claire pressed play again after the recording paused.

Elsie asked, “What happened to Dad?”

Ruth's breathing changed.

“He found the registry.”

“What registry?”

“The original placements. Names. Payments. Mothers who objected. Sloane wanted the copy.”

“Did Helena Vale know?”

“She came to the house.”

“When?”

“The night before Thomas died.”

Claire and Mara looked at each other.

Ruth's voice became sharper.

“She told him to give back what he stole. He said you cannot steal proof of your own crime. She said he had daughters and should think like a father.”

Elsie whispered, “Was that a threat?”

“Yes.”

“What happened the next day?”

“His brakes failed.”

Mara shut her eyes.

Claire's fingers went numb.

Ruth continued.

“Police said accident. Thomas had checked the car that morning. He always checked it. I knew.”

“Who took us?”

“County services came with papers. Gregory Sloane came too. Helena waited outside.”

“Why didn't you stop them?”

“I tried.”

Ruth's voice broke.

“They injected me.”

Mara sat on the pew.

Claire paused the recording.

Neither sister spoke for a long time.

Finally Mara said, “I remember her screaming.”

Claire stared at the dust on the floor.

“I remember someone singing from upstairs.”

“That was Mom.”

“You know?”

“She sang when she was scared.”

Claire began to cry.

Mara moved closer and held her.

For the first time since meeting, neither of them seemed uncertain about where to put their arms.

Owen turned his laptop around.

“I found Rosemere Cottage.”

They separated.

He showed them satellite images.

“Private road. Two buildings. No visible perimeter security, but there are cameras at the gate. There is a service road from the east.”

Claire wiped her face.

“Can we get police there?”

Owen nodded toward the audio file.

“This recording plus the bank documents may be enough for a welfare check.”

Claire's phone buzzed.

Lucas.

She answered immediately.

“What happened?”

His voice was tense.

“My mother admitted she knew your mother was alive.”

Mara leaned closer.

Claire put the call on speaker.

“What exactly did she say?”

Lucas took a breath.

“She said Ruth was unstable and dangerous, that my father arranged treatment after Thomas died.”

“Did you record it?”

“Yes.”

“Did she mention Rosemere Cottage?”

Silence.

Then, “How do you know about Rosemere?”

Claire looked at Mara.

“We found Elsie's drive.”

Lucas swore softly.

“Do not go there.”

Mara rolled her eyes.

“Here we go.”

Claire ignored her.

“Why?”

“Because my mother said something else. She told me if I wanted to protect you, I should convince you to stop looking before Sloane decides containment has failed.”

Owen leaned toward the phone.

“Did she say Sloane is acting independently?”

“No. She said she can still control him.”

Mara whispered, “That means she can't.”

Lucas continued.

“I left the estate and one of our security supervisors followed me. I lost him, but Claire, this is bigger than my mother.”

“Where are you?”

“Ten minutes from Naomi's office.”

“Call her. Send the recording to Owen.”

“I already did.”

Claire paused.

“Good.”

Lucas exhaled.

“Was that almost approval?”

“Don't get excited.”

Mara muttered, “Definitely still in love.”

Claire shot her a glare.

Lucas heard.

“I miss Mara already.”

“She despises you.”

“I know.”

“Lucas.”

His voice softened.

“Yes?”

“We found a recording of my mother saying Helena threatened Dad the night before he died.”

Silence.

“I'm sorry,” he said.

Claire closed her eyes.

“Your mother may have arranged his murder.”

“I know what that means.”

“Do you?”

“Yes.”

His voice shook now.

“It means I stop hoping there is a version of this where she is merely cruel.”

Claire had no answer.

Owen's second phone rang.

He looked at the screen and went pale.

“What?” Mara asked.

He answered.

“Owen Reed.”

A woman's voice came through faintly.

“Owen?”

He froze.

“Elsie?”

Mara lunged toward the phone.

“Elsie!”

Static cracked.

Then the younger woman's voice, weak and hurried.

“Don't go to Rosemere. It's empty.”

Mara grabbed the phone.

“Where are you?”

“I got out.”

“Out of where?”

“I don't know. A clinic. They moved Mom before they took me there.”

Claire stepped closer.

“Elsie, it's Claire.”

Silence.

Then a sob.

“You found her.”

Mara began crying.

“Yes, you maniac. We found her.”

Elsie laughed weakly.

“Hi, Claire.”

Claire pressed a fist to her mouth.

“Hi.”

Owen whispered, “Trace the call.”

Claire shook her head. They would not risk alerting whoever might be monitoring.

“Elsie, are you hurt?”

“Drugged. Bruised. Still irritating.”

Mara said, “Good.”

“I need you to listen. Sloane knows about box 317. He thinks Dad's master registry is there, but it isn't.”

Owen looked at the bank files.

“Then where?”

“Dad moved it.”

“How do you know?”

“Mom told me. The bank box is evidence pointing to the real place.”

Claire gripped the phone.

“Where is the registry?”

Elsie's breath sounded ragged.

“At the old chapel, but not in the pew. The brass bird is a key.”

Mara looked beneath the third pew.

The brass swallow had come loose when they twisted it.

Claire picked it up.

One wing ended in a narrow, notched stem.

A key.

Elsie whispered, “Behind the altar. Look for the carved nest.”

A car door slammed somewhere on her end.

Elsie gasped.

“Mara, I have to go.”

“No. Tell me where you are.”

“I don't know the road. There's an old water tower. Red letters. Harrow Feed.”

Owen was already typing.

“Got it.”

Mara clutched the phone.

“Elsie, stay with me.”

“I can't. They're looking.”

“Who?”

“Sloane's driver. And someone named Pike.”

Lucas's voice came through Claire's phone at the same time.

“Did she say Pike?”

“Yes.”

“My mother's head of security is Damian Pike.”

Mara's face hardened.

Elsie whispered, “I love you.”

Then the line died.

Mara stared at the phone.

Claire took her hand.

“She got out.”

“They can take her again.”

“We're going to find her.”

Owen pointed to the map.

“Harrow Feed. Forty-three miles west. There is a decommissioned water tower on County Route Six.”

Claire looked at the altar.

“And the registry?”

Mara's eyes moved between the brass bird and the road map.

Claire understood the choice.

Evidence or Elsie.

For a moment, her father's dead voice seemed to echo from the cassette.

Protect the girls.

Claire closed her fingers around the brass bird.

“Elsie first.”

Owen nodded.

Mara stared at Claire.

“You're sure?”

“Completely.”

They ran from the chapel without opening the hidden compartment behind the altar.

May you like

[COMPLETED] She waited ten years for her fiancé, but the night she marri...

[COMPLETED] Five Years After My Mafia Husband Chose Another Woman, He Me...

[COMPLETED] I CALLED MY HUSBAND 18 TIMES WHILE OUR SON WAS DYING. EIGHT...

The registry could wait.

Their sister could not.