Chapter 4 - What Clara's Mother Never Told Her

Clara called her mother from Roman’s underground records room.

The first call went unanswered.

The second went to voicemail.

On the third, Margaret Bennett finally picked up.

“Clara? I’m at the pharmacy. Can I call you back?”

“No.”

Her mother became quiet.

Clara stared at the photograph of Samuel Bennett standing beside Roman’s father.

“Mom, did Dad ever work for the Carmichael family?”

Nothing came through the line except the faint sound of a shopping cart rolling somewhere in the background.

Clara closed her eyes.

“Mom.”

Margaret whispered, “Where are you?”

That was the answer.

Clara’s stomach twisted.

“You knew.”

“Clara, where are you?”

“Did Dad work for them?”

A long silence.

“Yes.”

Clara turned away from Roman and Richard.

“How long?”

“Almost four years.”

“You told me he worked for Eberhardt Manufacturing.”

“He did. Before that.”

“You told me he never worked downtown.”

“I lied.”

The words landed harder than Clara expected.

“Why?”

“Because he made me promise.”

“Dad has been dead fourteen years.”

“I know.”

“Then why are you still protecting his secret?”

Margaret’s voice trembled.

“Because I was not protecting his secret. I was protecting you.”

Roman watched Clara from across the table.

She hated that his face looked concerned.

It made staying angry more difficult.

“From what?”

“Come home.”

“No.”

“Clara.”

“Tell me now.”

Her mother inhaled slowly.

“Not over the phone.”

Roman stepped closer.

“Ask her whether anyone contacted her recently.”

Margaret heard him.

“Who is that?”

Clara hesitated.

“Roman Carmichael.”

The line went dead.

Clara stared at the screen.

Roman said, “That was informative.”

“She hung up because your last name frightened her.”

“That was informative too.”

Clara immediately called again.

No answer.

Richard rubbed his forehead.

“Maybe we should go to her.”

Clara looked at him.

“You are not coming anywhere near my mother.”

“I was trying to help.”

“You already helped enough.”

Roman picked up the photograph.

“We go together.”

Clara looked at him.

“That sounded suspiciously like an order.”

“It was a proposal phrased efficiently.”

“No bodyguards in her house.”

“No visible bodyguards.”

“Roman.”

“One in the alley. One at the corner. Gabriel stays outside.”

Clara considered arguing.

Then she remembered the anonymous call.

“Fine.”

Richard stepped forward.

“What about me?”

Roman glanced at him.

“You are going somewhere secure until Emily is safe.”

Richard’s eyes narrowed.

“You mean detained.”

“I mean alive.”

Clara left before the argument could continue.

Her mother lived in a brick bungalow in Portage Park, the same house where Clara had spent most of her childhood.

When the sedan stopped half a block away, Roman looked out at the narrow street lined with snowbanks and bare trees.

“You grew up here?”

“Yes.”

“You kept the house?”

“My mother did.”

“After the fire?”

Clara’s hand tightened around the door handle.

“The fire was in our old apartment. We moved here afterward.”

Roman nodded.

He did not ask another question.

Margaret opened the front door before Clara knocked.

She was sixty-two, small and silver-haired, wearing a navy winter coat as if she had been preparing to leave.

Her eyes moved immediately to Roman.

“No.”

Clara stepped inside.

“Mom.”

Margaret backed away.

“He should not be here.”

Roman remained on the porch.

“I can wait outside.”

Margaret stared at him.

“You look like Anthony.”

Roman froze.

Clara looked between them.

“You knew his father?”

Margaret’s eyes filled.

“Unfortunately.”

Roman said quietly, “Mrs. Bennett, I found a letter from my father. It names Samuel.”

Margaret gripped the doorframe.

“Then Anthony failed.”

“What was he trying to do?” Clara asked.

Her mother looked at her.

“Keep the ledger hidden.”

Clara felt her heartbeat in her throat.

“The duplicate ledger?”

Margaret closed the door and locked it.

“Come downstairs.”

The basement smelled exactly as Clara remembered: laundry detergent, old wood, dust, and the faint metallic warmth of the furnace.

Margaret switched on the lights.

Roman stood near the stairs, deliberately keeping distance.

Clara noticed the gesture.

Her mother crossed to an old sewing cabinet.

She removed the bottom drawer.

Behind it was a narrow metal box.

Clara stared.

“That has been here the whole time?”

“No.”

Margaret took out a key from beneath her necklace.

“I moved it three times.”

She unlocked the box.

Inside were tax forms, photographs, newspaper clippings, and a cassette tape.

Roman’s eyes went to the tape.

Margaret saw him notice.

“That is not the ledger.”

“Where is it?”

“I do not know.”

Clara nearly laughed from frustration.

“Of course.”

Margaret reached for her hand.

“Your father did not tell me where he put it.”

“Why not?”

“Because Vincent Carmichael had already threatened us.”

Roman’s jaw tightened.

Margaret looked directly at him.

“Your uncle came to our apartment when Clara was eleven.”

Clara went cold.

“I never saw him.”

“You were at school.”

“What did he want?”

“The ledger. Samuel had discovered Vincent was diverting money from legitimate Carmichael companies into shell partnerships. Not thousands. Tens of millions.”

Roman said, “My mother suspected that.”

“She was right.”

Margaret removed a photograph.

Anthony Carmichael, Roman’s father, stood in a restaurant booth beside Samuel.

A third man sat with them.

Clara recognized him from business articles.

“Everett Hale.”

Roman nodded slowly.

Margaret said, “Everett was not originally Vincent’s man. He was Anthony’s attorney.”

Roman looked startled.

Clara asked, “Then why did he threaten Richard?”

“Because people change when they believe they have no choices.”

Margaret sat down.

“Anthony discovered what Vincent was doing. He asked Samuel to create a clean duplicate ledger outside the company’s official books. Everett was supposed to prepare evidence for federal investigators.”

Roman’s voice was low.

“Why did none of that happen?”

Margaret looked at him with pity.

“Because your father died.”

Roman did not react outwardly.

Clara knew him well enough now to see the reaction anyway.

Margaret continued.

“After Anthony died, Vincent demanded the duplicate records. Samuel refused. Everett disappeared for almost a year. Your mother tried to hold the family together.”

“And Vincent?” Roman asked.

“He became more dangerous.”

Clara sat beside her mother.

“Dad’s fire.”

Margaret’s hands began shaking.

“The official report said faulty wiring.”

“Yes.”

“It was not faulty wiring.”

Clara stopped breathing.

Margaret’s voice cracked.

“Samuel called me that afternoon. He told me not to take you home. He said someone had searched the apartment.”

“Why did you go back?”

“I didn’t.”

Margaret looked down.

“Your father did.”

Clara closed her eyes.

“He went for the ledger.”

“I think he went to move it.”

“And the fire started while he was inside.”

“Yes.”

Clara stood so quickly the chair scraped across concrete.

For fourteen years, she had carried the memory of a fire truck reflected in wet pavement, her mother gripping her shoulders, a police officer kneeling to say there had been an accident.

Not murder.

Not Vincent.

Not secrets.

An accident.

“You let me believe he died because of bad wiring.”

Margaret stood too.

“I was trying to give you a childhood.”

“You gave me a lie.”

“I gave you distance from people who had already killed your father.”

Clara’s eyes filled.

Roman moved one step forward.

She raised a hand without looking at him.

“Don’t.”

He stopped.

Margaret whispered, “I am sorry.”

Clara turned away.

Roman asked, “What is on the tape?”

Margaret wiped her face.

“Samuel recorded a conversation with Vincent.”

Roman’s focus sharpened.

“Do you have a player?”

Margaret pointed to an old stereo on a shelf.

Clara laughed through tears.

“You kept a cassette player for fourteen years?”

“I kept everything he touched.”

Margaret inserted the tape.

Static filled the basement.

Then Samuel Bennett’s voice emerged.

Clara had not heard her father speak since she was twelve.

Her knees nearly gave out.

“Vincent, you cannot move that money without Anthony seeing it.”

Another man answered.

“Anthony sees what I permit him to see.”

Roman’s face changed.

Vincent.

Samuel said, “If you forge the trust authority, the transactions will unravel.”

“Only if someone possesses the original ledger.”

“You will never find it.”

Vincent laughed.

“Everyone says that before I find what they love.”

The recording clicked.

A different conversation began.

Everett Hale this time.

“Sam, Anthony is dead. We need to stop.”

Samuel said, “That is why we cannot stop.”

“I have a wife.”

“So do I.”

“I have children.”

“So does Anthony.”

A pause.

Everett whispered, “Vincent says Roman will inherit everything. If we wait, maybe the boy can fix it.”

Samuel answered, “A seventeen-year-old should not have to repair crimes committed by grown men.”

Roman looked away.

Clara’s anger suddenly had nowhere to go.

The tape ended.

Margaret removed it.

Roman asked, “Did Samuel leave any clue about the ledger?”

Margaret hesitated.

“One sentence.”

“What sentence?”

“He told me, ‘If Clara ever needs the truth, give her the thing she always hated.’”

Clara stared.

“That could mean anything.”

Margaret almost smiled.

“No. It could not.”

She walked to a storage shelf.

From behind a box of Christmas ornaments, she pulled out a battered wooden case.

Clara recognized it immediately.

“Oh, no.”

Roman looked at her.

“What?”

“My father’s chess set.”

Margaret placed it on the table.

Clara laughed despite everything.

“I hated chess.”

“Samuel tried to teach you every Sunday,” Margaret said.

“I used to hide the pieces.”

“Yes.”

Roman opened the box.

Thirty-two carved pieces rested inside.

Clara picked up the white queen.

“He always said the queen was the most dangerous piece because everyone watched her.”

Roman examined the board.

“Anything unusual?”

Clara stared at the pieces.

Then she remembered.

“The black rook.”

“What about it?”

“I broke it when I was eight. Dad replaced it.”

She lifted the black rook.

It felt heavier than the others.

Roman took a small knife from his pocket.

Clara raised an eyebrow.

“You just carry that?”

“Yes.”

“Of course you do.”

He carefully pried at the felt base.

It came loose.

Inside was a tiny brass key.

Margaret covered her mouth.

“I never knew.”

Clara held the key in her palm.

A number was engraved into it.

317.

Roman stared at the number.

“Safe-deposit box.”

“Which bank?” Clara asked.

Margaret shook her head.

“No idea.”

Roman took the old photograph of Samuel and Anthony.

On the building behind them, barely visible over Samuel’s shoulder, was a stone sign.

FIRST PRAIRIE TRUST.

Roman looked at Clara.

“That bank was absorbed into Lake National fifteen years ago.”

Clara closed her fingers around the key.

“Then tomorrow we open box 317.”

Roman did not answer.

His phone vibrated upstairs.

A second later Gabriel called down.

“Roman.”

Something in his voice made everyone move.

They climbed the stairs.

Gabriel stood in the kitchen holding his phone.

“What happened?” Roman asked.

Gabriel looked at Clara first.

Then Roman.

“Thomas Vale was found.”

“Where?”

“O’Hare parking structure.”

“Alive?”

Gabriel hesitated.

“Yes.”

Roman’s shoulders eased slightly.

“Then why do you look like that?”

Gabriel turned the phone around.

A security image showed Thomas sitting alone in a parked car.

On the passenger seat beside him was a white envelope.

May you like

[COMPLETED] She waited ten years for her fiancé, but the night she marri...

[COMPLETED] Five Years After My Mafia Husband Chose Another Woman, He Me...

[COMPLETED] I CALLED MY HUSBAND 18 TIMES WHILE OUR SON WAS DYING. EIGHT...

Across the front, written in thick black marker, were two words.

FOR CLARA.