Chapter 4 - The Investigator Who Refused to Die

Harold Pike had spent three years pretending to be Henry Pierce.

He repaired boat engines near Biloxi.

He rented a room above a bait shop.

He paid cash.

He avoided banks.

He never stayed in restaurants long enough to finish dessert.

When Benny found him, Pike tried to run.

At sixty-eight, he made it twenty yards.

Benny caught him beside a shrimp boat.

Carmine arrived two hours later with Nell.

Pike took one look at her and sat hard on a wooden crate.

“Oh, God.”

Nell stopped. “You remember me.”

“Eleanor.”

“Nobody calls me that anymore.”

“I’m sorry.”

“For which part?”

Pike lowered his eyes. “All of it.”

Carmine stood behind her. Pike recognized him.

“Orsini.”

“You took money from my family.”

“I took money from Vincent Marrow.”

Nell stepped closer. “After my father nearly died.”

“Yes.”

“You changed the report.”

“Yes.”

“You wrote negligence.”

“Yes.”

“You knew the door was chained.”

“Yes.”

She slapped him.

The sound cracked across the dock.

Pike did not defend himself.

“My father spent three years believing nobody believed him.”

“I believed him.”

“That is worse.”

Pike nodded. “Yes.”

“Why?”

“I had two daughters.”

Nell laughed through tears. “So you destroyed someone else’s father for yours?”

“Vincent showed me photographs of my girls. Their school. Their cars. My wife leaving church.”

“He threatened them,” Carmine said.

“He never said the words.”

“He did not need to.”

“No.”

“And the eighty thousand?” Nell asked.

Pike’s shame deepened. “I took it.”

“Why?”

“Because fear explained the first lie. Greed paid for the rest.”

Silence.

Carmine respected the answer because Pike did not disguise himself as innocent.

“What happened?”

Pike rubbed his hands together. “I changed the report. Removed the chain. Removed a witness statement.”

Nell leaned forward. “What witness?”

“A delivery driver named Luis Ortega.”

“Where is he?”

“Dead.”

“When?”

“Car accident eight months after the fire.”

Carmine asked, “What did he see?”

“Two men by the rear door around one thirty. He recognized one.”

“Who?”

“Jerome Vale.”

Nell looked at Carmine.

“And the other?”

“Tall. Heavy coat. Gold ring.”

Nell whispered, “Vincent.”

“Maybe.”

“What else did Ortega say?”

“That Jerome carried a length of chain.”

Nell gripped the edge of the crate.

“Who started the fire?”

Pike looked away. “I don’t know.”

“You know more.”

“I think they expected the building empty.”

“You chain a door and then claim you expected emptiness?”

“I know how it sounds.”

“It sounds like attempted murder.”

“Yes.”

Pike looked directly at her.

“I do not ask you to forgive me.”

“Good.”

Carmine’s voice turned colder. “Who ordered it?”

“Vincent handled it.”

“That is not the same answer.”

“I never heard the order.”

“What about Alessandro?”

Pike looked at Carmine for a long time. “Your father wanted the property.”

Nell went still.

“But?” Carmine asked.

Pike hesitated. “I do not think he ordered the fire.”

“Why?”

“Because three days after the fire, Alessandro came to my office furious.”

Carmine’s expression changed. “Impossible.”

Pike frowned.

“My father died four years and two months ago.”

The color left Pike’s face.

“No.”

“The fire was three years and ten months ago.”

Pike stood.

“I saw him.”

“You saw a man.”

“He looked like Alessandro Orsini.”

“Did you know my father personally?”

Pike stopped.

“No.”

Nell whispered, “Someone impersonated him.”

Carmine turned away.

A.O. wants block cleared.

The Orsini ring.

The apparent anger after the fire.

Someone had used a dead man’s name because dead men could not deny signatures.

Pike opened an old metal cash box.

“I kept something.”

Benny raised an eyebrow. “What?”

Pike unlocked it.

Inside were photocopies.

The original fire report.

Luis Ortega’s witness statement.

A photograph of the rear door.

The steel chain looped through both handles.

A brass padlock blackened by smoke.

Nell stopped breathing.

Carmine touched her elbow.

She did not protest.

Pike laid down another page.

A hardware-store receipt.

Chain.

Padlock.

Gasoline can.

Paid cash.

On the back, handwritten in blue ink: J.V.

“Jerome Vale,” Nell whispered.

“I kept everything I was too cowardly to submit,” Pike said.

“Why did Vincent let you live?” Carmine asked.

“He didn’t. He sent men after me.”

“Then how are you alive?”

Pike looked at him. “Odette warned me.”

Nell’s eyes widened.

“Odette?”

“She called the night before they came.”

“What did she say?”

“Run.”

“Why?”

“She said she had already buried one innocent family and refused to bury another.”

The world became less simple again.

Odette had signed the bribe.

Odette had hidden evidence.

Odette had saved Pike.

Carmine asked, “What did Vincent have on her?”

“I don’t know.”

Benny’s phone rang.

He answered.

His face hardened. “Lock the house.”

Carmine turned.

Benny ended the call.

“What happened?”

“Palmira collapsed.”

“When?”

“Ten minutes ago.”

“Alive?”

“Yes. Ambulance is there.”

“And Odette?”

“Gone. Room empty. Car still there. Phone on the kitchen counter.”

Nell whispered, “Poison?”

“Unknown.”

Pike raised a hand. “There is one more thing.”

Carmine stopped.

“Vincent was not trying to buy only the bakery.”

“What?”

“The entire block.”

“For what?”

“A private river-access corridor.”

Benny frowned. “Magazine Street does not have river access.”

“Not on the surface.”

Pike explained the old Prohibition tunnels.

Brick passages beneath several buildings.

Liquor routes from another era.

Nell remembered something.

“Our basement had a sealed brick wall.”

Pike nodded. “That wall was part of the central junction.”

Her face drained.

The bakery had not been burned simply for a piece of property.

It had been burned because below its ovens was a route worth far more than the building.

Carmine’s phone rang.

A doctor confirmed Palmira had been drugged with sedatives.

Then another message arrived.

Unknown number.

A photograph.

Odette tied to a chair.

Bruised but alive.

Behind her, old brick.

Six words beneath the image:

BRING THE FONTAINE FILES TO THE TUNNEL.

During the drive back, Nell sat beside the old cash box.

She kept staring at the photograph of the chained door.

Carmine finally said, “Stop.”

“What?”

“You have memorized it.”

“I already had.”

“No. You memorized the idea of it. That is different.”

She folded the photograph. “I need it.”

“For what?”

“To prove I wasn’t crazy.”

“You were never crazy.”

“You did not know me then.”

“I know enough now.”

Nell looked out the window. “My father kept saying chain. Chain. Chain. Doctors thought he was confused.”

“And you?”

“I believed him.”

“Then why do you need proof?”

She swallowed. “Because believing someone alone is exhausting.”

Benny drove in silence for a moment.

Then he said, “Evidence lets other people carry some of the weight.”

Nell looked at him.

“That was almost profound.”

“Do not repeat it.”

“I’ll put it on a pillow.”

“I will burn the pillow.”

Nell laughed despite herself.

Carmine looked at Benny. “Good.”

Benny glared in the mirror. “What?”

“Nothing.”

For ten miles the car felt lighter.

Then Carmine looked again at the photograph of Odette.

“Whoever sent this thinks we still need the files.”

Benny nodded. “Meaning they do not know what Pike kept.”

Nell looked at the cash box.

“Then for once, we have something they don’t.”

Carmine’s eyes met hers.

“Yes.”

“What do we do?”

“We make them believe we are desperate.”

“Are we?”

“For my grandmother and Odette?”

He looked at the road ahead.

“Yes.”

Nell nodded.

“Good.”

Carmine frowned. “Good?”

“Fear means history.”

He remembered her words from his office.

She did too.

“Apparently,” he said.

Nell put the photograph away.

“Then let fear inform the plan.”

“Not make it.”

“Exactly.”

Benny muttered, “You two have been together four days and already have a philosophy.”

“We are not together,” Nell said.

Carmine looked out the window.

Benny smiled to himself.

The old investigator watched the car disappear, then looked toward the gray Gulf water.

For three years he had believed hiding was the same as surviving.

Now, for the first time, the truth had left his hands.

He was not relieved.

But he was no longer alone with it.

Before leaving Biloxi, Pike asked Nell to wait.

He took a second envelope from the cash box.

“I wrote this two years ago.”

“What is it?”

“A confession.”

She did not take it.

“Why write it if you were going to keep hiding?”

“Because I wanted there to be one version of the truth somewhere outside my head.”

“That did not help my father.”

“No.”

“Did not help me.”

“No.”

“Then why should I care?”

Pike looked at the dock.

“You should not. But if I die before trial, give it to whoever needs it.”

Nell took the envelope at last.

“Do you expect forgiveness because you are sorry?”

“No.”

“Good.”

“I expect to testify.”

“That is better.”

Pike looked at Carmine.

“Your father’s name will appear in all of this.”

“I know.”

“Some people will assume he ordered everything.”

“I know.”

“You could protect his reputation by limiting what you release.”

Carmine’s expression went cold.

“That is how we arrived here.”

Pike nodded.

Nell looked between them.

For the first time, she believed Carmine might truly be willing to let the Orsini name become smaller than the truth.

It was not redemption.

May you like

[COMPLETED] She waited ten years for her fiancé, but the night she marri...

[COMPLETED] Five Years After My Mafia Husband Chose Another Woman, He Me...

[COMPLETED] I CALLED MY HUSBAND 18 TIMES WHILE OUR SON WAS DYING. EIGHT...

Not yet.

But it was evidence.