Chapter 4 - The Copy from the Closet

Elaine wrote her statement at Mae’s kitchen table.

She wrote by hand first because she said typing made her feel as if she were preparing a report instead of remembering a conversation.

Mae sat across from her and did not interrupt.

“Summer,” Elaine said. “It was summer because I had the fan in the hallway.”

“Which year?”

“Two years ago. Maybe late July.”

“Don’t guess if you don’t know.”

Elaine looked up.

“That’s what your lawyer said?”

“That’s what I’m saying.”

Her mother gave a faint smile.

“Fair.”

She returned to the page.

Olivia had come for lunch.

She had asked about old photographs.

Then she had asked whether Elaine still had Mae’s “hospital novel.”

Elaine had said yes.

Olivia had said she was trying to remember details for a book she was drafting.

Elaine retrieved the printed manuscript from a plastic storage box in the hall closet.

Olivia borrowed it.

She returned it nine days later.

Mae asked, “Did she say she had Mae’s digital file?”

Elaine frowned.

“No.”

“Did she say Mae gave permission?”

“No.”

“Did she say she was using passages?”

“No.”

Mae stopped.

The questions sounded bizarre when spoken aloud.

Of course Olivia had not announced what she intended to do.

Still, the renewed access mattered.

Priya thought so too.

When they spoke by phone that afternoon, she said, “It directly undercuts the suggestion that the book arose only from old shared memories. It suggests deliberate consultation of the manuscript during the development period.”

“Does it prove copying?”

“Not by itself. But facts accumulate.”

Priya asked Elaine to provide a signed declaration.

Then she asked Mae whether the physical copy contained notes.

Mae and Elaine looked at each other.

“I don’t know,” Mae said.

The manuscript was still in Elaine’s closet.

They drove to the house.

Mae had grown up there, though the rooms felt smaller now. The wallpaper in the hallway had not changed since high school. Her father’s coat hooks still hung by the door, even though only Elaine’s scarf occupied one.

The closet smelled of cedar blocks.

Elaine pulled down the plastic box.

Inside were tax records, birthday cards, an old recipe book, photographs, and a thick manuscript clipped in two sections.

Mae recognized the title page.

Alder House.

By Mae Hart.

She touched the paper.

The pages had yellowed slightly at the edges.

Elaine said, “I’m sorry.”

“For keeping it?”

“For giving it to her.”

“You didn’t know.”

“I should have asked.”

Mae looked at her.

“No. She should have.”

They carried the manuscript to the dining table.

Halfway through chapter four, Mae noticed a pencil mark.

A vertical line in the margin.

Then another.

Then a small circle around a sentence.

She frowned.

“I didn’t do that.”

Elaine leaned closer.

“Are you sure?”

“I drafted digitally. I printed this for you. I never edited this copy.”

They kept turning pages.

More pencil marks appeared.

Not many.

But enough.

A bracket around the hospital corridor scene.

A star beside the mixed proverb.

A line under the fictional coat-letter discovery.

Mae’s mouth went dry.

“Do you recognize her handwriting?” Elaine asked.

“There aren’t words.”

Then, near the end, they found one.

Beside a paragraph about grief changing the meaning of an ordinary kitchen after someone dies, someone had written: use later.

Two words.

Small.

Slanted.

Mae stared.

Elaine whispered, “That’s Olivia’s handwriting.”

Mae knew it too.

Still, she did not photograph it and send it to social media.

She called Priya.

Within two hours, Priya arranged for a document examiner to photograph and preserve the manuscript before anyone handled it further.

Mae watched the pages being placed in protective sleeves.

The process felt excessive and absurd.

This was a family novel.

A thing she had once printed at a copy shop.

Now professionals wore gloves around it.

That evening, Fenwick & Rowe’s counsel contacted Priya again.

They wanted a meeting.

Mae joined by video the next morning.

Three people appeared on screen.

The publisher’s general counsel, Martin Lowe.

A senior editorial director named Celeste Ward.

And Olivia’s editor, Hannah Bloom.

Hannah looked miserable.

Martin spoke first.

“We want to be clear that the company takes your concerns seriously.”

Mae nodded.

Priya answered most of the procedural questions.

Then Celeste asked Mae to describe when she first recognized material.

“At the launch.”

“During Olivia’s reading?”

“Yes.”

“What passage?”

Mae told her.

Hannah looked down.

Celeste continued.

“When did you first provide the manuscript to Olivia?”

Mae gave the date.

“Was there any written agreement about how she could use it?”

“No.”

“Any oral permission?”

“No.”

“Did you ever ask her to collaborate?”

“No.”

“Did she ever ask you?”

“No.”

Then Hannah spoke.

“Mae, I need to ask something difficult.”

Mae waited.

“Olivia told me early in the editorial process that certain hospital scenes were based on family memories she and her sister had discussed.”

Mae felt Priya shift beside her.

“Did she name me?”

“Yes.”

“What exactly did she say?”

Martin interrupted.

“We can’t disclose privileged or confidential internal communications beyond what is appropriate at this stage.”

Priya said, “You can tell us what representation was made regarding my client’s contribution.”

A pause followed.

Then Celeste said, “Olivia represented that any family material incorporated into the manuscript had been shared voluntarily and that no one else claimed authorship.”

Mae laughed softly.

Not because it was funny.

Hannah looked stricken.

“I’m sorry,” she said.

Martin glanced at her.

Mae said, “Did she ever show you my manuscript?”

“No.”

“Did she tell you it existed?”

Hannah hesitated.

“Yes.”

The room seemed to narrow.

“When?”

“During the second revision.”

“What did she say?”

“That it was an abandoned family-writing exercise. Notes, mostly.”

Mae stared.

“Four hundred and twelve pages.”

Hannah’s face lost color.

“She did not describe it that way.”

Priya took over.

“Did your editorial team compare the submitted novel against Ms. Hart’s manuscript?”

“No,” Martin said.

“Because you did not have it.”

“Correct.”

“We will provide a forensic copy.”

Martin nodded.

“In return, we would like consent to have an independent expert conduct textual analysis.”

Priya looked at Mae.

Mae said, “Yes.”

The meeting ended after forty minutes.

Outside Priya’s office, Mae stood on the sidewalk and called no one.

She watched traffic.

A bus hissed at the curb.

People moved around her carrying groceries, coffee, backpacks.

The world did not look like a place where a family could split over paragraphs.

Her phone rang.

It was Jonah Pierce.

“I heard there’s movement,” he said.

“How?”

“Publishing is a village pretending to be an industry.”

Mae almost smiled.

“I can’t discuss details.”

“Good. Don’t.”

“I don’t know what I’m doing.”

“That’s less important than knowing what you won’t do.”

“What won’t I do?”

“That’s for you to decide.”

Mae thought.

“I won’t lie to protect her.”

“Good.”

“I won’t exaggerate to punish her.”

“Also good.”

“I won’t let my mother negotiate this.”

“Excellent.”

That made Mae laugh.

Jonah said, “And?”

Mae looked at the traffic.

“I won’t let this make me stop writing again.”

The words surprised her.

Jonah was quiet for a moment.

“Were you writing again?”

“No.”

“Maybe you are now.”

After they hung up, Mae went home and opened the old manuscript.

Not the evidence copy.

A clean digital duplicate.

She read the first chapter.

It was uneven.

Olivia had been right about that.

The voice shifted.

The pacing dragged.

Some scenes tried too hard to sound profound.

Mae could see every flaw.

She could also see what was alive.

A daughter trying to care for a father while resenting the sister who stayed away.

A mother refusing to discuss death.

A family using politeness to avoid fear.

Mae had abandoned the manuscript because she believed “unfinished” meant “failed.”

Perhaps that had been the most expensive lesson Olivia ever taught her.

At seven, an email arrived from Fenwick & Rowe.

All additional print orders for The House at Alder Street were being temporarily suspended pending review.

Mae read the sentence once.

Then again.

Her stomach turned.

She had asked them to investigate.

This was investigation.

Still, consequence had weight.

Five minutes later, Olivia called from a different number.

Mae answered before she could decide not to.

“You got the book frozen,” Olivia said.

“No. Your choices did.”

“Do you know what they told me?”

“No.”

“My paperback is on hold. Foreign publishers are pausing offers. My editor won’t discuss book two.”

“I’m sorry.”

Olivia made a sound of disbelief.

“Don’t.”

“I can be sorry you’re hurting and still not withdraw the complaint.”

“You could end this.”

“So could you.”

“How?”

“Tell the truth.”

“I have.”

Mae looked at the protected manuscript on her dining table.

“Did you write ‘use later’ in Mom’s copy?”

Silence.

Olivia said, “What?”

“You borrowed the manuscript two years ago.”

Another silence.

Mae heard breathing.

Then Olivia whispered, “Mom told you.”

“She remembered.”

“That doesn’t prove anything.”

“The note is in your handwriting.”

“You can’t know that.”

“We can test it.”

Olivia did not answer.

Mae’s anger faded into something sadder.

“Why did you go back for it?”

“I told you. I was trying to remember Dad.”

“No.”

“Mae—”

“You could have called me to remember Dad.”

Olivia’s voice broke slightly.

“I couldn’t.”

That was new.

Mae waited.

Olivia said, “You had the version of him I wanted.”

“What does that mean?”

“The one who needed you.”

Mae closed her eyes.

For the first time, the conflict opened onto something older than a manuscript.

But before Mae could ask more, Olivia said, “Forget it.”

She hung up.

Mae stared at the phone.

The question remained.

Why had Olivia needed Mae’s version of their father badly enough to take it?

May you like

[COMPLETED] She waited ten years for her fiancé, but the night she marri...

[COMPLETED] Five Years After My Mafia Husband Chose Another Woman, He Me...

[COMPLETED] I CALLED MY HUSBAND 18 TIMES WHILE OUR SON WAS DYING. EIGHT...

The answer would not excuse anything.

But Mae suspected it might explain why her sister had crossed the line in the first place.