Chapter 4 - The Cost of an Easy Answer

The legal aid office operated out of two rooms above a pharmacy on Main Street.

Holly had expected fluorescent lights, plastic chairs, and a tired attorney who would glance at the documents and tell them to come back in six weeks.

Instead, they met Nina Patel, a forty-three-year-old lawyer with bright red glasses, a stack of flood-disaster forms on her desk, and the unnerving habit of pausing before she answered anything important.

She read the power of attorney twice.

Dean had emailed the Northstar offer that morning. Nina read that too.

Then she placed both documents side by side.

“The good news,” she said, “is that your son cannot transfer title to your property under this document without your separate written authorization.”

Evelyn let out a breath.

“The bad news?”

“The phrase ‘bad news’ may be too strong.”

Nina tapped the page.

“He can negotiate, communicate, request inspections, collect documents, and sign certain administrative forms. He can also represent to third parties that he is acting on your behalf within those limits.”

Holly leaned forward.

“So if Northstar thinks he is authorized to negotiate, that part is true.”

“Yes.”

“Even if Mom did not understand the property language?”

“That affects whether she wishes to revoke it and potentially whether there was misrepresentation in obtaining it. But I would be careful about using words like fraud unless we have evidence of intent.”

Evelyn nodded.

“I want it revoked.”

“That is straightforward.”

Nina pulled a form from a folder.

“We’ll prepare a written revocation today. We should send copies to Northstar, the insurer, the county, and any law firm that received the original authorization.”

Holly glanced at the Northstar offer.

“Will revoking it cancel the offer?”

Nina looked at Evelyn.

“Possibly. Do you want the offer canceled?”

Evelyn surprised Holly by saying, “No.”

Holly turned.

“Mom?”

“I said I want to decide. I did not say I want to refuse because I am angry.”

Nina smiled slightly.

“That distinction will save you money in legal fees.”

Evelyn folded her hands.

“I want the offer kept open if they will keep it open. I want an independent appraisal. I want a structural assessment. I want to know what insurance will actually pay. Then I will decide.”

Nina nodded.

“Good. Those are manageable questions.”

Holly looked at the offer again.

The number was substantial. Enough to buy an accessible condo in town and leave money for future care. Enough that rejecting it for emotional reasons would be irresponsible.

That realization made her uncomfortable.

She had come into the office prepared to fight Dean.

Now she found herself asking whether part of his plan might actually be best for their mother.

Nina noticed her expression.

“Ms. Mercer?”

“Holly.”

“Holly, you look like someone just changed the problem.”

“They did.”

“That happens a lot in here.”

“I thought the issue was Dean trying to force a sale.”

“The issue may be that he tried to control the process. That does not automatically make every outcome he preferred wrong.”

Holly leaned back.

“You sound like Sam.”

“Is Sam another lawyer?”

“No. Annoyingly, he is just reasonable.”

Evelyn made a small sound that might have been a laugh.

Nina continued.

“One more question. Does Dean receive any direct compensation if Northstar acquires the property?”

Holly looked at Evelyn.

Neither knew.

Nina pointed to the conflict-of-interest section in the power of attorney.

“If he does, that matters. Even if he does not receive a commission, a promotion, performance bonus, or project incentive could create a personal interest. It does not automatically invalidate negotiations, but it should have been disclosed.”

Evelyn’s eyes sharpened.

“Ask him.”

Holly reached for her phone.

“Now?”

“Now.”

Dean answered on the first ring.

“What happened?”

Holly looked at Nina.

“Why do you assume something happened?”

“Because you don’t usually call me at ten in the morning.”

“Mom is with me. We’re at legal aid.”

A pause.

“Of course you are.”

Evelyn leaned toward the speaker.

“Do not start.”

Dean exhaled.

“Hi, Mom.”

“Nina Patel is helping me revoke the power of attorney.”

“All right.”

Holly blinked at his lack of resistance.

Evelyn continued.

“We have a question. Do you get any money if Northstar buys my house?”

“No commission.”

“That was not the question.”

Dean was silent for a second.

“My compensation includes an annual performance bonus.”

Holly closed her eyes.

“Based on what?”

“Division targets. Project completion. Revenue. Several metrics.”

“Would the Riverbend acquisition affect it?”

“In theory, yes.”

Evelyn’s voice went flat.

“Did you tell me that?”

“No.”

“Why?”

“Because I did not consider the amount meaningful compared with the value I was trying to get you.”

Nina raised one eyebrow.

Holly said, “That is something you disclose, Dean.”

“I understand that now.”

“You understood conflicts of interest before today. It is literally part of your job.”

“I wasn’t acting as a broker.”

“You were acting under Mom’s power of attorney while your employer negotiated to buy her property.”

Dean’s voice tightened.

“I got her a better offer than any outside buyer is going to make right now.”

“That is not the point.”

“It is one point.”

Evelyn cut in.

“I am revoking the power.”

“I heard you.”

“I am also requesting that Northstar communicate directly with Nina about the offer.”

Dean was quiet.

“Fine.”

“And I want every email involving my property.”

“Holly—”

“I said I want them,” Evelyn said.

Dean stopped.

“All right.”

“Today.”

“I’ll ask legal what I’m allowed to release.”

“You do that.”

Evelyn ended the call herself.

Nina waited.

Evelyn looked at the phone.

“That went better than I expected.”

Holly laughed.

“You threatened him with legal aid and his own mother. He never had a chance.”

For the first time since the flood, Evelyn laughed too.

It lasted only a few seconds, but Holly held onto the sound.

After the appointment, Sam drove them to the county disaster center for the structural assessment meeting. He had become, almost by accident, part of the logistics of their days. His own house had taken water in the crawlspace but remained habitable, so he volunteered mornings and repaired his property in the afternoons.

Holly worried she was accepting too much help.

Sam dismissed the concern.

“You spent six years bringing my aunt groceries every Friday.”

“Your aunt was my mother’s friend.”

“And she talked for forty-five minutes before letting you leave.”

“That part was harder than the groceries.”

“Consider this repayment with interest.”

The county engineer met them beside a temporary map board showing red, yellow, and green dots across the flood zone.

Evelyn’s house was marked yellow.

“Repairable,” he explained. “But substantial damage rules apply. Because the repair cost is likely over fifty percent of the structure’s pre-flood value, any rebuild has to meet current elevation standards.”

Holly looked at him.

“Meaning?”

“You either elevate the structure or rebuild the occupied floor above base flood elevation. Depending on foundation condition, elevation could cost a lot.”

“How much?” Evelyn asked.

He gave a range.

Even the low number made Holly’s stomach sink.

Insurance might cover part of it. Federal mitigation grants might cover part. But nothing would be fast.

“How long?” Holly asked.

“Best case? Six to nine months. Longer if permits back up.”

Evelyn stared at the map.

Dean’s sale option suddenly looked easier.

That was the problem with easy answers.

Sometimes they were easy because someone else had done the hard thinking.

Sometimes they were easy because the cost had been hidden.

Holly needed to know which kind Dean was offering.

They stopped for lunch at the diner across from the motel. Evelyn finally got her soup. Sam ordered coffee and pie. Holly stared at a legal pad where she had drawn two columns.

SELL and REBUILD.

Under SELL she had written:

Accessible housing sooner.

No construction risk.

Strong Northstar offer.

Leave neighborhood.

Lose home.

Possible conflict with Dean.

Under REBUILD:

Keep property.

Stay near neighbors.

Expensive elevation.

Months displaced.

Flood risk remains.

Grant uncertainty.

Evelyn read over her shoulder.

“You forgot one.”

“What?”

“Under both columns: I get to choose.”

Holly wrote it across the bottom of the page.

Sam sipped his coffee.

“That may be the most expensive line on the list.”

Evelyn pointed her spoon at him.

“Do not make jokes about my independence.”

“I wouldn’t dare.”

“You just did.”

“I made a joke about paperwork.”

“Coward.”

Sam smiled.

Holly watched them and felt something in her chest loosen.

The flood had turned everything into urgent decisions—where to sleep, what to save, what to sign, what to throw away. Sitting in a diner while her mother argued about soup and insulted Sam felt almost ordinary.

Then Holly’s phone buzzed.

An email from Dean.

Subject: Riverbend Records.

Attached were twenty-seven files.

Insurance forms. Appraisals. Northstar correspondence. County maps. Internal project memos.

Holly opened the first few at the table.

Dean had sent more than she expected.

Then she opened an email chain from six weeks earlier.

Marla Quinn had written:

We need the Mercer parcel to secure south access. If Dean can bring it in voluntarily, I can recommend moving him onto the Riverbend project lead once acquisition closes.

Below it was Dean’s reply.

I’ll speak with her. Do not contact my mother directly.

Holly’s pulse quickened.

Evelyn noticed.

“What?”

Holly turned the phone so she could read.

Evelyn read both messages.

Her expression did not change.

Sam looked away, deliberately not intruding.

Holly whispered, “Project lead.”

Evelyn continued reading.

There was another message lower in the chain.

Marla: We need a clean story on voluntary acquisition. No family dispute, no elder-pressure optics. If she hesitates, wait. We cannot afford bad press around a resilience project.

Dean: Understood.

The message was not proof of a conspiracy.

If anything, Marla had instructed Dean not to pressure Evelyn.

But the offer of a project lead was exactly the kind of personal benefit Nina had told them to look for.

Holly scrolled farther.

Then she found an attachment titled COMMUNITY RESPONSE - FLOOD ACTIVATION PLAN.

The date was three weeks before the flood.

Northstar had prewritten disaster-response templates for multiple areas near its proposed development zones. That alone was not suspicious; large companies planned for emergencies.

But one line made Holly stop.

Priority communications opportunity: Riverbend corridor. Emphasize company commitment to long-term resilience and recovery.

Below it was a note from Marla to Dean.

If Graywater rises again this season, be ready. Riverbend may become politically possible faster than the council process.

Holly read the sentence twice.

Sam leaned toward her.

“What is it?”

She showed him.

His mouth flattened.

Evelyn set down her spoon.

“They were waiting for a flood.”

“No,” Holly said carefully. “They were preparing for one.”

“Is there a difference?”

“Yes.”

She thought of how badly she wanted the answer to be simple.

Dean had lied about her. He had concealed his own interest. His employer had seen disaster as an opportunity.

Those facts were enough to be angry about.

She did not need to invent worse ones.

Sam nodded, as if he heard the choice she was making.

“Preparation isn’t causation,” he said.

Evelyn looked at him.

“I know that.”

“But it does tell you how they were thinking.”

Holly stared again at Marla’s phrase.

Politically possible faster.

The flood had destroyed kitchens, bedrooms, photographs, and routines.

To Northstar, it had also changed a timetable.

Holly closed the email.

“Dean said he’ll ask legal what else he can release.”

Evelyn lifted her spoon again.

“Good.”

“What do you want to do with this?”

Her mother took one bite of soup before answering.

“Nothing yet.”

Holly blinked.

“Nothing?”

“We asked for facts. We got facts.”

“They offered him the project lead.”

“Yes.”

“You’re not angry?”

“I am furious.”

“Then why—”

“Because anger does not require immediate motion.”

Evelyn looked directly at her.

“That is a lesson both my children could stand to learn.”

Holly sat back.

Sam hid a smile behind his coffee cup.

Evelyn pointed at him again.

“And you can stop enjoying this.”

“I’m terrified of you, Mrs. Mercer.”

“Good.”

Holly laughed despite herself.

Outside, a relief truck rolled past the diner toward Riverbend Road.

The side panel carried Northstar’s blue logo.

For the first time, Holly did not see the logo as proof of guilt or generosity.

She saw it as evidence of power.

May you like

[COMPLETED] She waited ten years for her fiancé, but the night she marri...

[COMPLETED] Five Years After My Mafia Husband Chose Another Woman, He Me...

[COMPLETED] I CALLED MY HUSBAND 18 TIMES WHILE OUR SON WAS DYING. EIGHT...

And she understood that if her family was going to make a decision freely, they would need something they had not had since the water began to rise.

Time.