Chapter 4 - The Storefront Without a Client

The following morning, I went to Somerville with Priya.
I didn't go there to investigate Nathan on my own. Sofia knew where we were, and Julian had asked us to document only what could be observed from public areas. He was already requesting business records through proper channels.
The storefront was on a narrow commercial street beside a coffee shop and a dry cleaner. Its windows were covered with brown paper. A small notice on the door referred to unfinished renovation work, but the posted contractor information was several months old.
Three years earlier, someone had asked Northline to design the interior for a proposed retail tenant. I remembered the request because the budget had made no sense. The person contacting us wanted drawings before there was any reliable financing for construction.
I declined the work.
Nothing about that decision should have mattered to Nathan's family.
Yet Richard had been shown this address as part of the growth arrangement supposedly supporting my studio.
Priya photographed the outside of the property without entering. I checked our project archives on my phone. The old inquiry showed an unsigned estimate and my short email refusing the commission.
“Someone used the existence of a real inquiry to make it look like we were involved,” Priya said.
That was the first explanation that fit everything we had seen.
We returned to the office before noon. Julian met us there with an early comparison of the documents Richard had provided. The Carter family transfers totaled exactly four hundred and eighty thousand dollars. Every wire went to the separate entity managed by Nathan. None passed through Northline Design's business accounts.
“That's good news for your studio,” Julian said. “It isn't the end of the question.”
He laid out the first and second quarterly reports Nathan had sent his father. The reports presented revenue projections and progress photographs for several ventures, including the Somerville site.
One photograph was from Northline's actual restaurant project in Cambridge. It had been cropped to remove the client's name.
Another showed sketches from the rejected Somerville inquiry, an unsigned concept sheet that a prospective client had supplied to explain the kind of space he wanted. Northline had never produced the drawings.
Nathan had placed both images beneath a description of development milestones.
“Who made these reports?” I asked.
“We don't know yet. The versions Richard preserved identify Nathan as the sender. That's different from knowing who prepared each page.”
I appreciated Julian's caution even when it made the process frustrating.
My phone rang while he was explaining the next steps.
Margaret.
I let it go to voicemail.
She left a message asking me to reconsider the attorney and suggesting we could solve the problem over dinner. There was no apology for the previous morning, and no acknowledgment that the investment might have been misrepresented.
I forwarded the recording to Sofia.
She replied that ordinary communication could continue if I wanted, but any proposed settlement needed to go through counsel. I didn't want a family dinner. I wanted the financial truth.
Late that afternoon, Nathan arrived outside Northline's office.
Priya came to tell me he was waiting on the sidewalk. He had not entered, and he wasn't threatening anyone. I went down to speak with him because I wanted to hear what he would say when his parents weren't present.
He looked as though he hadn't slept.
“Richard has frozen everything,” he said before I could speak.
I watched him.
“You mean his money?”
“The remaining funding. He's demanding records from the development company.”
“Then give him the records.”
Nathan glanced across the street.
“You don't understand how complicated it became.”
“That phrase doesn't make information disappear.”
He lowered his voice.
“I was trying to build something of my own.”
The admission struck me harder than an excuse might have.
For years, he had described my studio to other people as a small venture he helped support. Sometimes he called it our business. I had corrected him privately when the phrasing became too generous. He always laughed and said I was being overly precise.
Now I understood how convenient imprecision had been for him.
“You could have built something,” I said. “You didn't have to use my name to do it.”
He didn't deny that he had.
Instead, he told me the first Somerville deal had stalled after a tenant withdrew. He had expected to replace the tenant, finish the renovation, and repay the early family investment with a profit. When costs rose, he asked Richard for additional capital.
“Did you tell him Northline Design was participating?”
“I told him I could get design work through you.”
“That isn't the same thing.”
He stared at the pavement.
“It started as something that could have been true.”
I had never heard a more revealing description of a lie.
Nathan asked whether I could tell Richard the design relationship had merely been informal. He said no one had to accuse anyone of wrongdoing if we treated the paperwork as confused.
I thought of the signature in blue script.
“Did you sign my name?”
He looked directly at me for one second and then away.
I waited.
He said he wanted a lawyer present.
It was the first sensible thing he had said since the hotel, and it did nothing to reassure me.
When he left, I returned upstairs and told Sofia exactly what had happened. She made a note of Nathan's statements but advised me not to approach him again about the documents.
That evening, Julian called with another discovery.
He had identified a series of small payments back to Richard marked as investment distributions. They did not come from Northline Design. They came from Nathan's company account shortly after additional family funds were deposited.
The timing raised a question about whether the returns had been earned at all.
Julian was careful not to label the transfers before reviewing the complete account history.
“But there's another problem,” he said. “The second investment package contains an ownership schedule.”
He sent the page to Sofia and me.
The schedule purported to grant Richard a twenty-four percent economic interest linked to Northline Design's future growth.
I had never approved any sale of ownership in my company.
My name appeared beneath that schedule too.
The same blue script.
May you like
For the first time since the hotel, I stopped thinking only about what Nathan had taken from me emotionally.
He had promised somebody a piece of the business I had built without them.