Chapter 8 - The Offer They Wanted Us to Accept

The first settlement proposal arrived two days before our mediation. Novak's attorney offered a single payment to each current employee in exchange for a release of every wage claim, including any claim involving retaliation. The amounts were larger than our regular pay envelopes, but smaller than the hours we'd documented.
I stared at the figures until they began to blur. For years, any unexpected money had meant immediate relief. This time I had to ask what I would be giving away to receive it.
Marisol read the proposal with us in her office. Leila and the other employees sat around the table, each holding a copy. No one spoke at first. One man said he needed money for his electricity bill. Another was afraid the bakery would close before we saw a dollar. I understood both fears because they were my own.
“It's your decision whether to settle,” Marisol said. “But I want you to understand the difference between money offered because they want the problem to end and money supported by the hours you actually worked.”
She showed us her calculations. The original schedules, register logs, and statements supported more substantial claims than Novak's proposal reflected. Some periods would require further verification. She wouldn't promise we would recover every dollar. But we did not have to sign a release that pretended the missing hours had never existed.
I went home with the documents in my bag. Rosie was coloring at the kitchen table. She held up a picture of a bakery with a bright red door.
“That's where you work now,” she announced.
“Mrs. Rivera's place?”
She nodded. “I made it bigger.”
I sat beside her and looked at the impossible little building she had created with a few pencils. She had given it room for a garden and a window full of cakes. There was no fear of rent notices or unpaid hours in her picture. I wanted a life where she could keep imagining places like that without wondering whether I would be working the following morning.
At mediation, Mr. Novak attended with his attorney. I hadn't seen him since the day he handed me the unsigned release. He appeared older, though I knew that was partly because I had stopped seeing him only as the person who determined whether I would get a shift.
He admitted the schedules accurately recorded work he had not paid for. His attorney proposed a revised arrangement: verified unpaid wages and an additional negotiated amount for the disputed retaliatory reduction, with payments beginning immediately and continuing under a binding schedule. Marisol insisted on clear deadlines, financial disclosures sufficient to assess the plan, and provisions protecting employees who returned to work or gave evidence.
“What happens if he misses a payment?” Leila asked.
The mediator explained the enforcement terms. No one asked us to trust a promise that wasn't written down.
The negotiations lasted hours. They were not dramatic. Most of the time, people were checking figures, comparing dates, and working out what the bakery could pay without promising money it did not have. That ordinary care mattered. I'd already heard enough grand assurances from people who could not be bothered to count our hours.
When we finally left, we had a proposed agreement we could review, not an ultimatum. Each worker could accept or continue a claim independently. There was no demand that we stop speaking about the property assessments. The bakery's wage debts and the landlord's unauthorized collections would remain legally separate.
Outside, Mr. Novak approached me before I reached the sidewalk.
“I thought I could keep the place alive until things improved,” he said. “I kept telling myself no one would be hurt if I paid it back later.”
“You knew people were being hurt,” I replied. “We told you.”
He looked down. “I know.”
For a moment I remembered the warm bakery on dark mornings, the early trays coming out of the oven, and how grateful I'd been when he first hired me. Those memories were real. So were the missing wages. I didn't need to erase one to acknowledge the other.
“I hope you keep the bakery,” I said. “But it can't survive by taking what your workers need to live.”
He nodded and walked away. I didn't follow him.
That evening, a report about Moretti Property Group appeared in a local business publication. The company confirmed an internal investigation into unauthorized fees collected from several commercial tenants and announced that an independent accounting firm was reviewing its property practices. It did not identify me or the bakery employees. It named Sloane as a suspended manager under investigation, with no conclusion about criminal responsibility.
Dominic had kept his promise to make the problem public enough for affected tenants to come forward. What troubled me was the statement attributed to a company spokesperson saying the scheme appeared to be the work of one individual.
One person might have diverted the money. But other people had allowed the system to function without scrutiny. I called Tomas and asked whether Dominic had seen the statement. Tomas said he had, and that Dominic wanted to speak with me.
I agreed to a brief call. “Your company says one employee did this,” I told him. “Is that what you believe?”
“I believe the evidence points to Sloane directing the assessments.”
“That's not what I asked.”
He was quiet. Then he said, “No. I don't believe one employee explains everything.”
“Will you say that where the tenants can hear you?”
“There's a board review next week. Affected tenants can speak through the independent review process. I'm willing to say it there.”
I hadn't expected an invitation to matter to me. I was a bakery worker, not a property investor. Then I remembered the red stamp on Mr. Novak's notice and how easily he'd accepted a copied signature as the final word. People like us had obeyed decisions made by people we'd never meet. Perhaps the people making those decisions needed to meet us for once.
I asked Marisol whether speaking would threaten our wage agreement. She said we could keep the issues separate and that I should speak only to what I knew firsthand. She would accompany me.
That night, I took Rosie's bus ticket out of the drawer where I'd been keeping it safe. The pencil lines had softened from handling. She had drawn two shoes that looked nothing like a store advertisement. They were simple and a little uneven, and I loved them more than the originals.
May you like
For a while, I'd wanted to hide that drawing from everyone who might see how little I could afford. Now it reminded me of a different truth. Rosie had found something she could make when she couldn't buy what she wanted. I had mistaken surviving for accepting. Perhaps I could do something more than survive.
I placed the ticket in my bag before the board meeting. I wasn't taking it as proof of anybody's wrongdoing. I was taking it to remember why I had decided not to sign my silence away.