Chapter 17 - What Claire Returned

Claire came to the house once more before the divorce was finalized.

She asked first.

That mattered.

I almost suggested a café again, but Noah had a mild cold and I did not want to take him out. So I told her she could come for twenty minutes.

She arrived with a cashier's check and a small wooden box.

"I'm not taking gifts," I said from the doorway.

"The box isn't a gift."

I let her in.

She looked around the living room without curiosity, as if she understood that every object here belonged to a life she had already intruded upon enough.

Noah slept in his bassinet.

Claire stopped several feet away.

"He's beautiful."

"Thank you."

She did not ask to hold him.

She handed me the check first.

It was for the remainder of the medical money not covered by the clinic refund.

"Claire, this is too much."

"It's what I can repay now. Ethan already reimbursed the joint account, so his attorney told me technically this belongs to him. I told him I didn't care. He told me to give it to you for Noah's medical savings."

I stared at her.

"He said that?"

"Yes."

I set the check on the table.

"And the box?"

Claire opened it.

Inside was a silver watch.

I recognized it immediately.

Ethan had worn it when we first met. It had belonged to Simon, Claire's younger brother.

"Why do you have this?"

"Ethan gave it to me in Zurich."

My stomach tightened.

"When?"

"After the kiss."

"Why?"

"He said he had carried Simon's death long enough and wanted me to have the watch back."

I looked at the scratched silver face.

"That's why he stayed, isn't it?"

"Partly."

Claire sat on the edge of the chair.

"After Simon died, Ethan wore that watch almost every day. I used to think it was because he loved him. Later I realized it was punishment."

"He told me about the accident."

"Then you know the police cleared him."

"He never cleared himself."

"No."

Claire touched the box.

"In Zurich, my illness became another version of Simon. If I survived, maybe Ethan could finally believe he wasn't someone who abandoned people when they needed him."

I looked at her.

"Except he abandoned me to prove he wasn't an abandoner."

"Yes."

The tragedy of it was almost too neat.

"Why bring me the watch?"

"Because he left it with me, but I don't want to keep being the keeper of his guilt."

"Then give it to him."

"I tried. He said he doesn't want it back."

"So why me?"

Claire looked toward Noah.

"Because someday Ethan may tell his son about Simon. If he does, the watch should be part of a story, not a punishment."

I considered that.

"I'll keep it for Noah. Not for Ethan."

"That's what I hoped."

We sat quietly.

Finally, I asked, "How are you? Medically."

"My last scans were clear. They won't use the word cured yet, but the treatment worked."

"I'm glad."

She blinked, surprised.

I was surprised too.

But I meant it.

"Thank you."

"Being angry at you doesn't require me to wish you dead."

"That's a very low bar."

"We're not close enough for high bars."

She laughed, and the sound eased something in the room.

Then her face grew serious.

"I am moving to Boston. My sister is there. I accepted a job with a nonprofit that supports patients in long-term treatment."

"That's good."

"I won't contact Ethan again."

"That's between you and Ethan."

"I know. I just wanted you to know I'm not waiting in the background."

I looked at her for a long moment.

"You were never the whole problem."

Her eyes lowered.

"No. But I was part of it."

"Yes."

That was as close to forgiveness as I could offer.

When she stood to leave, Noah woke and began to fuss.

I picked him up.

Claire watched from the doorway.

"Goodbye, Noah," she said softly.

Then she looked at me.

"Goodbye, Rachel."

"Goodbye, Claire."

After she left, I placed Simon's watch in the top drawer of Noah's dresser beside the hospital bracelet from the night he was born.

Two objects from two disasters Ethan had survived differently.

One had trapped him in guilt for years.

The other had finally forced him to face it.

I closed the drawer.

For several minutes I stood beside Noah's crib and listened to him breathe. Simon had died young. Claire had nearly died. Noah and I had nearly died. Ethan had spent years trying to bargain with loss as if enough vigilance in the next crisis could rewrite the previous one. I finally saw the pattern without feeling responsible for breaking it on his behalf. That work belonged to him.

May you like

[COMPLETED] I Found the Mafia Boss Breathing in His Casket—Then He Refus...

[COMPLETED] My Mafia Boss Husband Spent the Night with His “Little Siste...

[COMPLETED] My Husband Slapped Me at the Country Club While I Was Pregna...

My work was different. I had to stop measuring compassion by how much of myself I could surrender before asking someone else to notice. I had mistaken endurance for strength for too long.

The past could be remembered without being obeyed.