Chapter 2 - The Door He Thought He Owned

I turned toward Dante with my hand still resting on the sedan's chrome handle. Anthony stood on the other side of the rear door, perfectly still. The doors to the Halcyon Grand were behind my husband, throwing warm light across the pavement. Somewhere upstairs, the party continued as though nothing had happened.

"You think an apology is what I'm waiting for?" I asked.

Dante's expression hardened. "I think you need to stop making decisions while you're upset."

"You just threatened to punish me for leaving."

"I said we should talk."

"No. You said if I got into the car, I wouldn't get an apology. Those are different things."

His gaze moved briefly toward Anthony. I had seen that look at business dinners. It meant a conversation had become inconvenient because someone less powerful could hear it. Once, I had mistaken that kind of control for discipline. Now it made me feel tired.

"Anthony," I said, "please open the door."

The driver's hand moved toward the handle, then hesitated. He looked at Dante without meaning to. I didn't blame him. Dante signed his paychecks, and everyone who worked for us understood how little patience my husband had for being contradicted.

"He doesn't need permission to do his job," I said.

"Elena." Dante lowered his voice. "You don't know what you're saying."

"I know you laughed while your friends joked about me. I know you said you could sleep with anyone you wanted. And I know you followed me outside instead of saying you were sorry."

For a moment, he looked as though he might finally answer the accusation. Instead he glanced toward the glass doors. Two guests had reached the lobby, not close enough to hear us, but close enough to recognize him.

"Come home," he said. "We will discuss this privately."

"If I come home with you, will you listen?"

He paused. "I always listen."

I thought about the phone calls answered while I was still speaking. The canceled dinners. The mornings when he came home exhausted and expected me to be grateful that he'd returned at all.

"You listen until you don't like the answer."

He drew a breath. I could see the argument he wanted to make assembling itself behind his eyes: his responsibilities, his enemies, the sacrifices he'd made for us. Every time I questioned our marriage, we somehow ended up discussing the danger of his work. None of it explained what he'd said in the ballroom.

"Where will you go?" he demanded.

"Somewhere I can think without being told what my feelings mean."

"You can't just disappear in Manhattan."

"I'm not disappearing. I'm leaving a party."

Anthony opened the rear door. The interior lights came on. I knew that car; I had ridden in it to anniversaries, funerals, and charity dinners, sometimes with Dante's hand resting over mine. Tonight, the open door felt like a choice I was making for myself.

Dante reached toward my arm, then stopped before touching me. "I didn't mean it the way you heard it."

"Then tell me what you meant. Right now."

He opened his mouth and closed it again. For the first time that evening, he had no answer prepared.

"That's what I thought."

I got into the car. Anthony shut the door gently, walked around the hood, and took his place behind the wheel. Dante stood outside, his dark suit catching reflections from the hotel lamps. As we pulled away, I saw him lift his phone. He didn't look angry anymore. He looked astonished that the car had actually moved.

We drove several blocks without speaking. The city was full of people going somewhere with someone they loved. I watched couples outside restaurants, a woman laughing beside a taxi, strangers waiting at a crosswalk. It was ordinary life. I had missed ordinary life more than I realized.

"Mrs. Caruso," Anthony said carefully, "where would you like to go?"

My first instinct was to give him our home address. Eight years of habit were difficult to undo. Instead I asked him to take me to a hotel near the river where I could book a room. I had my own bank card and my identification. I didn't need Dante to arrange everything.

"If Mr. Caruso calls," Anthony said, "he may ask where I left you."

I studied the back of his head. Anthony had driven us for years. He had seen our marriage from the front seat, close enough to notice silences but too professional to comment on them.

"You can tell him you drove me somewhere safe," I said. "Please don't tell him the room number."

"I wouldn't know your room number, ma'am."

He said it so simply that I almost smiled. I understood the courtesy in the answer. He would deliver me to the entrance and give my husband nothing more exact than that.

At the hotel, I checked in myself while Anthony waited by the car. Dante called twice before I reached the elevator. I didn't answer. When the third call arrived, it came with a message: We need to talk before this gets out of hand.

I read it once. He still believed the problem was the size of my reaction, not the ugliness of his words.

In my room, I took off my earrings and set them beside the phone. I looked in the mirror at the woman who had walked into a ballroom believing she could survive another disappointing evening. My eyes were red, but my breathing had steadied.

I wrote one message: I am safe. I will contact you tomorrow. Do not send anyone to find me. Do not ask Anthony for my location.

I pressed send before I could rewrite it into something softer.

Dante replied almost immediately: You're my wife. I have a right to know where you are.

I sat on the edge of the bed, staring at those words. He had not asked if I needed anything. He hadn't asked whether I was frightened, or whether I had somewhere to sleep. His first answer was about a right he believed he possessed.

I turned the phone facedown. For the first time that night, there was no one else in the room to tell me what I was allowed to feel. I was frightened of tomorrow, but I was also certain of one thing: I would not go home simply because Dante expected me to.

Then another message arrived, this one from Anthony's number.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

He didn't tell Mr. Caruso the hotel name, it said. But Mr. Caruso has asked me to report to the house in the morning.

I looked at the screen for a long time. The night had begun with an insult. Now it was becoming a question about how far Dante would go to make sure my choices still belonged to him.