validate

Chapter 4 - The Men Who Thought It Was Funny

Nico answered on Sunday morning before his phone had finished ringing. He sounded less assured than he had under the chandeliers. I could still picture his smile disappearing when he first saw me standing behind Dante.

"I should have called you that night," he said.

"You were busy laughing."

"You're right."

That answer surprised me. I had expected him to defend Dante, or at least warn me not to embarrass the Caruso name. Instead, he admitted what he'd done without asking me to make him feel better.

"Tell me what happened before I came over," I said.

Nico explained that the six men had been talking about a pending commercial-property venture involving Caruso Atlantic Holdings. One of them had joked that Dante had to consult me before agreeing to anything. Dante disliked being challenged in front of men who measured authority by how loudly it was asserted. The first joke became another. Then somebody asked whether I kept him on a leash.

"He could have told them to stop," Nico said. "He could have walked away. He didn't. We laughed because he expected us to."

"Had he said things like that before?"

Nico hesitated. "Not those exact words. But he talks about being untouchable. Sometimes he uses you as proof he doesn't answer to anyone."

I sat at the hotel desk and tried to absorb that. The wound from Friday night was not a single careless remark. It belonged to a habit of making our marriage look small whenever his pride was at stake.

"Do you know whether he's actually been with another woman?" I asked.

"I don't know," Nico replied. "And I won't pretend I do. I've seen him leave late. I've heard things. But I wasn't there, and gossip isn't evidence."

It was the most honest answer anyone in Dante's circle had given me in years. It was also terrifying, because it left the question untouched.

"Why are you telling me this?"

"Because I saw your face. Because I laughed. And because he is telling himself that what happened doesn't count."

Nico offered to speak to Dante again. I told him not to become a messenger between us. If my husband had something to say, he could say it directly and accept that I might not like the answer.

At the hotel, I spent the afternoon sorting the few documents I had with me. There was no secret account, no hidden key, no dramatic proof waiting inside my purse. There were ordinary marriage records: insurance information, statements from joint household accounts, a photograph of our anniversary dinner from years ago. I realized how much of our daily life was managed by staff and people answerable to Dante. I could access some of the accounts, but almost every practical request had traditionally gone through his office.

The dependency hadn't happened overnight. It was a series of easy decisions, most of which had seemed harmless when I made them. Why arrange a ride when Anthony was available? Why handle invitations when the household office already knew everyone's schedule? Why spend an afternoon managing paperwork when Dante's assistants could finish it in minutes? Slowly, convenience had become a life that was difficult to separate from his.

I wrote a list of what I needed to reclaim: identification records, photographs of my family, clothing, the few pieces of jewelry given to me by people other than Dante, and the materials from my old work. Nothing on the list required anyone else's approval. That realization was smaller than a victory, but it was real.

By evening a photograph from the Halcyon Grand had begun circulating in private social messages. It showed Dante standing with his companions. The caption repeated part of the joke about a leash. I couldn't tell who had first shared it. I could tell that the humiliation I had tried to leave in the ballroom was becoming something other people discussed without my consent.

Dante called after I forwarded him the image.

"I'll have that taken down," he said immediately.

"You can't make people forget what they heard."

"People twist things. I was speaking to men who were trying to provoke me."

"And you answered by offering them my dignity."

"I didn't offer anyone anything."

I closed my eyes. We were circling the same words again. He was arguing over the language while I was asking whether he understood its meaning.

"Nico told me what happened before I arrived," I said.

Silence.

"Nico should have kept his mouth shut."

"He should have told you to keep yours shut."

Dante inhaled sharply. "You're turning my people against me."

"They are your people, Dante. I'm your wife. Try to hear the difference."

I expected an explosion. Instead he spoke quietly, almost wearily.

"I never meant for you to hear that."

"That is not a defense."

He didn't reply. For an instant, I thought he might understand. Then he said that rumors about the incident could damage business relationships and that we needed to present a united front.

"I won't perform a happy marriage so strangers can trust your deals," I told him.

"I'm trying to protect us."

"That's what you always say."

I ended the call and sat for several minutes without moving. The room around me was quiet. My mind wasn't.

Ruth phoned shortly afterward. A lawyer representing Dante had sent a request to arrange an informal discussion of household matters. Ruth advised that we use a clear written schedule for my visit to the house rather than allowing the conversation to become a demand that I return. She also said I could decline any public statement about the marriage.

We fixed Tuesday afternoon for collecting my personal belongings. Dante agreed to be elsewhere while I was there. Anthony would drive me, and Ruth would arrange for someone from her office to attend. The plan was simple enough that I wondered why establishing it had required two attorneys.

Just before midnight, Dante sent one more message: I know you're angry. But you can't let six stupid words ruin eight years.

I read it, then opened the notebook I'd begun on Saturday. I copied his sentence beneath his boast. He was still telling me how much my anger was allowed to weigh.

I wrote back: I need you to answer one question. Have you ever been unfaithful to me?

The message showed as delivered. Several minutes passed with no reply. Then the typing indicator appeared, disappeared, and appeared again.

Finally, Dante sent three words.

May you like

We should talk.

I stared at the screen. It was the first answer he'd given that made me afraid of the truth.

Related Stories

Other posts