Chapter 5 - The Answer Behind the Joke

On Monday morning, I met Ruth in an office that contained no photographs of famous clients and no evidence that she had ever worked for Dante Caruso. She listened while I described the message I'd sent and the answer I'd received. We should talk. It was not a denial.

"You don't have to meet him today," she said.

"I want an answer."

"Then let him know exactly what question he is coming to answer. And remember that you can end the meeting whenever you choose."

Ruth allowed us to use a small conference room in her building that afternoon. It was neutral ground. I could see the door, and no one connected to Dante would decide when our conversation was finished. I was surprised by how much that mattered to me.

Dante arrived five minutes early. He wore a dark suit, his expression controlled, but he stopped when he saw I hadn't risen to greet him. He was accustomed to people standing when he entered a room. It seemed to take an effort for him to sit opposite me without commenting on it.

"You look tired," he said.

"Answer the question, Dante."

"I know you think—"

"Have you ever been unfaithful to me?"

He looked at his hands. For several seconds I heard nothing except voices passing in the corridor outside.

"Yes," he said.

There it was. One word. No dramatic confession, no letter falling out of a drawer, no photograph held under his nose. Just the answer I had been frightened to ask and a man who could no longer persuade me it was a misunderstanding.

"When?"

"Eighteen months ago. Boston. After a business dinner."

I remembered that weekend. Dante had called to say a transportation dispute would keep him away another night. I had eaten alone at home and told him to get some sleep when he could. I had been proud of being the kind of wife who understood his work.

"Was it someone who worked for you?"

"No. She was there with another company. We met after the dinner. It was one night."

"And you came home and let me think you were working?"

"Yes."

"You kissed me when you got home."

His eyes closed briefly. "I know."

I hated how ordinary his voice sounded. I had imagined that an admission like this would be accompanied by some visible change in the room. The chairs remained still. A car passed outside. Dante sat opposite me looking miserable, and I was still the person who had to decide what to do next.

"Were there others?" I asked.

"No."

"I don't know whether I believe you."

"I know I have no right to demand that you do."

That was the first sensible thing he'd said since Friday. It did not restore my trust. It only made clear how little of it remained.

I asked why he had done it. Dante tried twice to explain the dinner, the drinking, and the arrogance of men who congratulated one another for having no limits. I stopped him before those circumstances became excuses.

"You decided to go with her."

"I did."

"You decided to lie afterward."

"Yes."

"And on Friday you stood in front of those same kinds of men and laughed about doing it again."

He didn't deny that either. The boast had been an attempt to look untouchable to people whose respect he valued. It had also revealed something true about him: he had believed the rules of marriage could bend around his desires, provided I never found out.

He reached across the table, then withdrew his hand before it reached mine.

"I love you, Elena."

I looked at him. I believed he felt something powerful when he said it. I no longer believed that feeling made him trustworthy.

"Love didn't stop you in Boston," I said. "It didn't stop you on Friday. And it didn't make you apologize when I tried to leave."

"I was scared you'd go."

"You threatened me because you were scared?"

"I wanted you to stay and fight with me. If you were angry, I thought I could convince you. When you got into the car, I realized I couldn't."

His explanation was honest enough to be ugly. He would rather have controlled an argument than accepted that I had the right to walk away from it.

I asked whether anyone else knew about Boston. He said he had not told his friends or staff, and he couldn't know whether the woman had spoken about it. Nico's uncertainty had been genuine, at least as far as Dante knew. I decided not to turn the woman into an enemy I could question until my pain made sense. Dante was the one who owed me fidelity.

"What do you want me to do?" he asked.

I almost answered with the list that had lived inside me for years: come home, stay, listen, put down the phone, remember an anniversary without being reminded. Those requests belonged to a time when I had believed ordinary consideration might be enough to repair the distance between us.

Instead, I said, "I want you to stop asking me to make this easier for you."

He lowered his eyes.

"I'm sorry I cheated," he said. "I'm sorry I lied. I'm sorry I made you look small in front of those men."

I heard the difference between this and his earlier apology about the joke hurting me. He was naming what he had done, not only how I had reacted. Still, I couldn't make the words reach back eighteen months or erase the woman I'd been when I trusted his explanation about Boston.

"I need time," I said.

"How much?"

"I don't know. You don't get to set the deadline."

He nodded once, slowly. He looked as though he wanted to argue. For once, he didn't.

I stood to leave. Dante remained seated. At the door, I turned back because one more thing mattered.

"If you tell someone we are separating because I overreacted to a joke, you will be lying again."

"I won't."

I wanted to trust that promise. I couldn't.

When I returned to Ruth's office, she didn't ask for intimate details. I told her there had been an admission of infidelity and that I wanted to understand what a separation would involve. She explained the difference between preparing a petition and filing one, and why neither step required me to accept an agreement drafted by Dante's people.

May you like

[COMPLETED] “GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY DRESS! YOU’RE NOTHING BUT AN OLD SEAM...

[COMPLETED] At the Mafia Boss's Engagement Party, I Served His Hungry So...

[COMPLETED] The Mafia Boss’s Fiancée Tried to Dismiss His Father’s Loyal...

That night, I put my wedding ring inside the hotel safe. I didn't throw it away. It had been on my hand for eight years, and I wasn't ready to pretend those years had meant nothing.

But the ring was no longer on my finger. For the first time, Dante would have to speak to a wife who was deciding whether she still wished to be married to him.